TabM: Advancing Tabular Deep Learning With Parameter-Efficient Ensembling

📜 arXiv 💻 Usage 📚 Other tabular DL projects

TL;DR: TabM is a simple and powerful tabular DL architecture that efficiently imitates an ensemble of MLPs.

Tip

For a quick overview of the paper, see the abstract, Figure 1 and Page 7 in the PDF.

Using TabM in practice

To use TabM outside of this repository, you only need the following:

tabm_reference.py: the minimal single-file implementation.
example.ipynb: the end-to-end example of training TabM.
The section about hyperparameters.

To use tabm_reference.py, install the following dependencies:

torch>=2.0,<3
rtdl_num_embeddings>=0.0.11,<0.1

Then, either clone this repository and add its path to PYTHONPATH, or simply copy tabm_reference.py. After that, the following will work:

from tabm_reference import Model

Table of contents

Using TabM in practice
Overview
Set up the environment
Running the code
Adding new datasets
How to cite

Overview

The repository provides:

The official implementation of the TabM and MLP models.
The code for training and hyperparameter tuning used in the paper.
Hyperparameter tuning spaces, tuned hyperparameters and metrics of the models on all 40+ datasets used in the paper.

Models

The following models are available in this repository.

Tip

Among the TabM models, the following variations are recommended as a starting point:

$\mathrm{TabM}$ as the basic version.
$\mathrm{TabM_{mini}^\dagger}$ as the advanced version.

Name	Comment
$\mathrm{MLP}$	The plain multilayer perceptron (MLP)
$\mathrm{MLP^\dagger}$	MLP with the piecewise-linear embeddings
$\mathrm{MLP^\ddagger}$	MLP with the periodic embeddings (also known as MLP-PLR)
$\mathrm{MLP^{\ddagger(lite)}}$	MLP with the lite periodic embeddings
$\mathrm{TabM_{mini}}$	TabM-mini
$\mathrm{TabM}$	TabM
$\mathrm{TabM_{mini}^\dagger}$	TabM-mini with the piecewise-linear embeddings
$\mathrm{TabM^\dagger}$	TabM with the piecewise-linear embeddings

Hyperparameters

This section covers default hyperparameters and hyperparameter tuning.

Default hyperparameters

While there are no "official" default hyperparameters, the available tuned hyperparameters on 40+ dataset allow obtaining a reasonable configuration for the first run.

Show how

import json
from pathlib import Path

import pandas as pd

model = 'tabm'  # Or any other model from the exp/ directory.

# Load all training runs.
df = pd.json_normalize([
    json.loads(x.read_text())
    for x in Path('exp').glob(f'{model}/**/0-evaluation/*/report.json')
])
print(df.shape)  # (1290, 181)
df.head()

def get_dataset_name(dataset_path: str) -> str:
    """
    >>> get_dataset_name('data/california')
    'california'
    >>> get_dataset_name('data/regression-num-large-0-year')
    'year'
    """
    name = dataset_path.removeprefix('data/')
    return (
        name.split('-', 4)[-1]  # The "why" benchmark.
        if name.startswith(('classif-', 'regression-'))
        else name
    )


df['Dataset'] = df['config.data.path'].map(get_dataset_name)

# The hyperparameters.
hyperparameters = [
    'config.model.k',
    'config.model.backbone.n_blocks',
    'config.model.backbone.d_block',
    'config.model.backbone.dropout',
    'config.optimizer.lr',
    'config.optimizer.weight_decay',
]

# When summarizing hyperparameters (but not metrics),
# it is enough to keep only one seed per dataset.
dfh = df.loc[df['config.seed'] == 0, ['Dataset', *hyperparameters]]

# Add additional "hyperparameters".
dfh['has_dropout'] = (dfh['config.model.backbone.dropout'] > 0).astype(float)
dfh['has_weight_decay'] = (dfh['config.optimizer.weight_decay'] > 0).astype(float)

# Some datasets have multiple splits, so they must be aggregated first.
dfh = dfh.groupby('Dataset').mean()

# Finally, compute the statistics.
# NOTE: it is important to take all statistics into account, especially the quantiles,
# not only the mean value, because the latter is not robust to outliers.
dfh.describe()

Additional notes

First, the above approach is not expected to result in a universally powerful configuration. Generally, the more robust to hyperparameters the model is, the higher is the chance to compose a configuration that will be a reasonable starting point on a larger number of datasets.

Second, when computing the above statistics, a seemingly natural idea is to use only those datasets that are more similar to the task at hand. Also, not all used datasets are equally representative for the real world usage. However, deciding if a given dataset is relevant for the target task is not trivial. For example, generally, filtering datasets by size may not be a reliable criteria.

One idea is to split datasets into different groups, compute statistics separately for each group, and thus get better intuition on hyperparameters. Examples of groups:

By split type: "datasets with random splits" and "datasets with domain-aware splits" (this separation is used in the paper).
By GBDT/DL-friendliness: "datasets where GBDT performs well" and "datasets where DL performs well".
etc.

Based on the above approach, the following configurations can be suggested as a starting point for TabM with the AdamW optimizer:

Note

The suggested hyperparameters may change in the future.

Hyperparameter	$\mathrm{TabM}$	$\mathrm{TabM_{mini}^\dagger}$
`k`	32	32
Depth	3	2
Width	512	512
Dropout	0.1	TODO
Bins	N/A	TODO
Learning rate	0.002	TODO
Weight decay	0.0003	TODO

Hyperparameter tuning

Note

This section only provides general advice on hyperparameter tuning. Running the hyperparameter tuning code used in the paper is discussed later in this document, and requires setting up the environment.

If achieving the highest possible performance is not critical, then 30-50 iterations of the TPE sampler from Optuna should result in a somewhat reasonable configuration. It the paper:

For MLP, 100 iterations were used.
For TabM, 100 iterations were used on smaller datasets, and 50 iterations on larger datasets.

Metrics

The published results allow easily summarizing the metrics of the models on all datasets.

Show how

import json
from pathlib import Path

import pandas as pd

def get_dataset_name(dataset_path: str) -> str:
    """
    >>> get_dataset_name('data/california')
    'california'
    >>> get_dataset_name('data/regression-num-large-0-year')
    'year'
    """
    name = dataset_path.removeprefix('data/')
    return (
        name.split('-', 4)[-1]  # The "why" benchmark.
        if name.startswith(('classif-', 'regression-'))
        else name
    )

model = 'tabm'  # Or any other model from the exp/ directory.

# Load all training runs.
df = pd.json_normalize([
    json.loads(x.read_text())
    for x in Path('exp').glob(f'{model}/**/0-evaluation/*/report.json')
])
df['Dataset'] = df['config.data.path'].map(get_dataset_name)

# Aggregate the results over the random seeds.
print(df.groupby('Dataset')['metrics.test.score'].agg(['mean', 'std']))

The output exactly matches the metrics reported in the very last section of the paper:

                                             mean         std
Dataset                                                      
Ailerons                                -0.000157    0.000002
Bike_Sharing_Demand                    -42.108096    0.501597
Brazilian_houses                        -0.044310    0.021299
KDDCup09_upselling                       0.800227    0.010331
MagicTelescope                           0.860680    0.005765
Mercedes_Benz_Greener_Manufacturing     -8.221496    0.894050
MiamiHousing2016                        -0.148294    0.003001
MiniBooNE                                0.950001    0.000545
OnlineNewsPopularity                    -0.858395    0.000325
SGEMM_GPU_kernel_performance            -0.015809    0.000385
adult                                    0.858158    0.001100
analcatdata_supreme                     -0.077736    0.009874
bank-marketing                           0.790799    0.006795
black-friday                            -0.687502    0.001464
california                              -0.450932    0.003154
churn                                    0.861300    0.002463
cooking-time                            -0.480330    0.000587
covtype2                                 0.971188    0.000800
cpu_act                                 -2.193951    0.052341
credit                                   0.775121    0.004241
delivery-eta                            -0.550962    0.001511
diamond                                 -0.134209    0.001725
ecom-offers                              0.594809    0.000557
elevators                               -0.001853    0.000025
fifa                                    -0.797377    0.014414
higgs-small                              0.738256    0.002775
homecredit-default                       0.858349    0.001019
homesite-insurance                       0.964121    0.000401
house                               -30002.387181  181.962989
house_sales                             -0.169186    0.001056
isolet                                  -1.883108    0.119444
jannis                                   0.806610    0.001525
kdd_ipums_la_97-small                    0.884546    0.006317
maps-routing                            -0.161169    0.000120
medical_charges                         -0.081265    0.000052
microsoft                               -0.743353    0.000265
nyc-taxi-green-dec-2016                 -0.386578    0.000596
otto                                     0.826756    0.001436
particulate-matter-ukair-2017           -0.368573    0.000628
phoneme                                  0.870065    0.016701
pol                                     -3.359482    0.401706
road-safety                              0.794583    0.001253
sberbank-housing                        -0.246943    0.003539
sulfur                                  -0.019162    0.003538
superconduct                           -10.337929    0.033769
visualizing_soil                        -0.124183    0.018830
weather                                 -1.478620    0.003926
wine                                     0.796127    0.013558
wine_quality                            -0.616949    0.012259
year                                    -8.870127    0.011037

Set up the environment

Software

Clone the repository:

git clone https://github.com/yandex-research/tabm
cd tabm

Install any of the following tools, and follow the remaining instructions.

Tool	Supported OS	Supported devices
Pixi	Linux, macOS	CPU, GPU
Micromamba	Linux	GPU
Mamba	Linux	GPU
Conda	Linux	GPU

What is Pixi?

Pixi is a high-level tool built on top of Conda environments.

The main benefits:

Pixi allows running the code seamlessly across different operating systems, with and without GPUs (this projects supports only Linux and macOS).
Pixi guarantees that you and your collaborators will always have exactly the same Conda environment. If anyone adds/removes/updates a package, the enviroment is updated for all collaborators through the pixi.lock file. In particular, you will have exactly the same environment as us, the original authors.

Technical details:

Pixi is a single binary file that can be downloaded and run as-is. Thus, Pixi will not affect your current installations of pip, uv, conda, and of any other tools.
Pixi will automatically create and manage Conda environments in the .pixi folder right in the root of this repository. No need for manually creating the environment, installing packages, etc. At any moment, it is totally safe to remove the .pixi directory from the root of this repository.
All Pixi commands must be run from the root of the repository.

For more details, see the official Pixi documentation.

With Pixi, the environment will be created automatically when you do pixi run or pixi shell for the first time. For example, try:

# Running commands in the environment with GPU
pixi run -e cuda python -c "import torch; print(torch.cuda.is_available())"

# Running commands in the CPU-only environment
pixi run python --version

Or, if you prefer the Conda style workflow:

# Activate the environment with GPU
pixi shell -e cuda

# Activate the CPU-only environment
pixi shell

# Running commands (without `pixi run`)
python --version

# Deactivate the environment
exit

With Micromamba:

micromamba create -f environment.yaml
micromamba activate tabm

With Mamba:

mamba create -f environment.yaml
mamba activate tabm

With Conda:

conda create -f environment.yaml -n tabm
conda activate tabm

Data

License: we do not impose any new license restrictions in addition to the original licenses of the used dataset. See the paper to learn about the dataset sources.

The data consists of two parts.

Part 1. Go to the root of the repository and run:

mkdir local
wget https://huggingface.co/datasets/rototoHF/tabm-data/resolve/main/data.tar -O local/tabm-data.tar.gz
mkdir data
tar -xvf local/tabm-data.tar.gz -C data

Part 2. Create the local directory and download the TabReD benchmark to local/tabred (you will need an account on Kaggle). Then, run:

python tools/prepare_tabred.py local/tabred data

Quick test

To check that the environment is configured correctly, run the following command and wait for the training to finish. Please, note:

The first run in a newly created environment can be (very) slow to start.
The results of the experiment will not be representative. It is needed only to test the environment.

# Pixi with GPU
pixi run -e cuda python bin/model.py exp/debug/0.toml --force

# Pixi without GPU
pixi run python bin/model.py exp/debug/0.toml --force

# Without Pixi
python bin/model.py exp/debug/0.toml --force

The last line of the output log should look like this:

[<<<] exp/debug/0 | <date & time>

Editor settings

To make the Python language server more responsive, it is recommended to hide the exp directory from the language server. For example, in Visual Studio Code, this can be achieved by adding the following to the local .vscode/settings.json file of this project:

{
    // NOTE
    // If this setting is already configured on the user level,
    // you may need to duplicate the user-level values here.
    "python.analysis.exclude": [ "**/exp" ],
}

Running the code

This section will be useful if you are planning any of the following:

Reproducing the results from the paper.
Tuning and training the models on custom datasets.
Using this repository as a starting point for future work.

Code overview

Code	Comment
`bin/model.py`	The implementation of TabM and the training pipeline
`bin/tune.py`	Hyperparameter tuning
`bin/evaluate.py`	Evaluating a model under multiple random seeds
`bin/ensemble.py`	Evaluate an ensemble of models
`bin/go.py`	`bin/tune.py` + `bin/evaluate.py` + `bin/ensemble.py`
`lib`	Common utilities used by the scripts in `bin`
`exp`	Hyperparameters and metrics of the models on all datasets
`tools`	Additional technical tools

The exp directory is structured as follows:

exp/
  <model>/
    <dataset>/       # Or why/<dataset> or tabred/<dataset>
      0-tuning.toml  # The hyperparameter tuning config
      0-tuning/      # The result of the hyperparameter tuning
      0-evaluation/  # The evaluation under multiple random seeds

Models

All available models are represented by the Model class from bin/model.py. They differ in the arch_type, k, num_embeddings and bins arguments. The values for these arguments can be inferred from the TOML configs in the exp directory, and from the bin/model.py script, where Model is used.

The following table is the mapping between the models and their subdirectories in exp.

Model	Experiments
$\mathrm{MLP}$	`exp/mlp`
$\mathrm{MLP^\dagger}$	`exp/mlp-piecewiselinear`
$\mathrm{MLP^\ddagger}$	`exp/mlp-periodic`
$\mathrm{MLP^{\ddagger(lite)}}$	`exp/mlp-periodiclite`
$\mathrm{TabM_{mini}}$	`exp/tabm-mini`
$\mathrm{TabM}$	`exp/tabm`
$\mathrm{TabM_{mini}^\dagger}$	`exp/tabm-mini-piecewiselinear`
$\mathrm{TabM^\dagger}$	`exp/tabm-piecewiselinear`

Common guidelines

On your first reading, feel free to skip this section.

Show

bin/model.py takes one TOML config as the input and produces a directory next to the config as the output. For example, the command python bin/model.py exp/hello/world.toml will produce the directory exp/hello/world. The report.json file in the output directory is the main result of the run: it contains all metrics and hyperparameters.
The same applies to bin/tune.py.
Some scripts support the --continue flag to continue the execution of an interrupted run.
Some scripts support the --force flag to overwrite the existing result and run the script from scratch.
The layout in the exp directory can be arbitrary; the current layout is just our convention.

Training

To train a model once, compose a TOML config with hyperparameters and pass it to bin/model.py. For example, the following command reproduces one training run of TabM on the California Housing dataset:

mkdir -p exp/reproduce/train-once
cp exp/tabm/california/0-evaluation/0.toml exp/reproduce/train-once/
python bin/model.py exp/reproduce/train-once/0.toml

The output will be located in the 0 directory next to the TOML config.

Hyperparameter tuning

Use bin/tune.py to tune hyperparameters for bin/model.py. For example, the following commands reproduce the hyperparameter runing of TabM on the California Housing dataset (this takes around one hour on NVIDIA A100):

mkdir -p exp/reproduce/tabm/california
cp exp/tabm/california/0-tuning.toml exp/reproduce/tabm/california
python bin/tune.py exp/reproduce/tabm/california/0-tuning.toml --continue

Evaluation

Use bin/evaluate.py to train a model under multiple random seeds. For example, the following command evaluates the tuned TabM from the previous section:

python bin/evaluate.py exp/reproduce/tabm/california/0-tuning

To evaluate a manually composed config for bin/model.py, create a directory with a name ending with -evaluation, and put the config with the name 0.toml in it. Then, pass the directory as the argument to bin/evaluate.py. For example:

# The config is stored at exp/<any/path>/0-evaluation/0.toml
python bin/evaluate.py exp/<any/path>/0-evaluation

Ensembling

Use bin/ensemble.py to compute metrics for an ensemble of already trained models. For example, the following command evaluates an ensemble of the evaluated TabM from the previous section:

python bin/ensemble.py exp/reproduce/tabm/california/0-evaluation

Automating all of the above

Use bin/go.py to run hyperparameter tuning, evaluation and ensembling with a single command. For example, all the above steps can be implemented as follows:

mkdir -p exp/reproduce/tabm-go/california
cp exp/tabm/california/0-tuning.toml exp/reproduce/tabm-go/california

python bin/go.py exp/reproduce/tabm-go/california/0-tuning --continue

Adding new datasets

New datasets must follow the layout and NumPy data types of the datasets in data/.

Let's assume your dataset is called my-dataset. Then, create the data/my-dataset directory with the following layout:

data/
  my-dataset/
    # Continuous features, if presented
    # NumPy data type: np.float32
    X_num_train.npy
    X_num_val.npy
    X_num_test.npy

    # Categorical features, if presented
    # NumPy data type: np.str_ (i.e. string)
    X_cat_train.npy
    X_cat_val.npy
    X_cat_test.npy

    # Binary features, if presented
    # NumPy data type: np.float32
    X_bin_train.npy
    X_bin_val.npy
    X_bin_test.npy

    # Labels
    # NumPy data type (regression): np.float32
    # NumPy data type (classification): np.int64
    Y_train.npy
    Y_val.npy
    Y_test.npy

    # Dataset information in the JSON format:
    # {
    #     (required) "task_type": < "regression" or "binclass" or "multiclass"     >,
    #     (optional) "name":      < The full dataset name, e.g. "My Dataset"       >,
    #     (optional) "id":        < Any string unique across all datasets in data/ >
    # 
    # }
    info.json

    # Just an empty file
    READY

How to cite

@article{gorishniy2024tabm,
    title={{TabM: Advancing Tabular Deep Learning With Parameter-Efficient Ensembling}},
    author={Yury Gorishniy and Akim Kotelnikov and Artem Babenko},
    journal={{arXiv}},
    volume={2410.24210},
    year={2024},
}

Provide feedback

Saved searches

Use saved searches to filter your results more quickly

Repository files navigation

TabM: Advancing Tabular Deep Learning With Parameter-Efficient Ensembling

Using TabM in practice

Overview

Models

Hyperparameters

Metrics

Set up the environment

Software

Data

Quick test

Editor settings

Running the code

Code overview

Common guidelines

Training

Hyperparameter tuning

Evaluation

Ensembling

Automating all of the above

Adding new datasets

How to cite

About

Releases

Packages

Contributors 2

Languages

Name		Name	Last commit message	Last commit date
Latest commit History 35 Commits
bin		bin
exp		exp
lib		lib
tools		tools
.gitattributes		.gitattributes
.gitignore		.gitignore
LICENSE		LICENSE
README.md		README.md
environment.yaml		environment.yaml
example.ipynb		example.ipynb
pixi.lock		pixi.lock
pyproject.toml		pyproject.toml
tabm_reference.py		tabm_reference.py

License

yandex-research/tabm

Folders and files

Latest commit

History

Repository files navigation

TabM: Advancing Tabular Deep Learning With Parameter-Efficient Ensembling

Using TabM in practice

Overview

Models

Hyperparameters

Metrics

Set up the environment

Software

Data

Quick test

Editor settings

Running the code

Code overview

Common guidelines

Training

Hyperparameter tuning

Evaluation

Ensembling

Automating all of the above

Adding new datasets

How to cite

About

Resources

License

Stars

Watchers

Forks

Releases

Packages 0

Contributors 2

Languages

Packages