Fabric mod for completely rewriting the vanilla light engine.
Check out The issues tab Please note that since this is a beta, there could be some (severe) light corrupting issues. Do not use if you do not want to take that risk!
- seed:
vanillakekw - CPU: Intel i7-8750H @ 2.20GHz (Turboboost disabled)
- Benchmark 101x101 chunks syncloaded centered at (0,0), Warmup 101x101 chunks syncloaded centered at (-10000, -10000)
- CPU time was measured by forcing the light executor to be single threaded, which allowed very simple CPU thread time measuring via visualvm.
- Starlight implementation was tested on Tuinity
The data shows everything we need to know. Starlight took ~7 seconds to generate the light, while Vanilla's light engine took ~220s seconds. Phosphor took ~170s. Compared to the best mod available (Phosphor), Starlight is about 25 times faster at generating light for chunks - and about 35 times faster than the vanilla light engine.
Starlight will relight vanilla lit chunks due to a difference in how sky light is managed, and the new skylight data is incompatible with the vanilla skylight format. However, when vanilla loads the chunks, it will simply relight the chunks, so the save format is compatible with vanilla. If you are going to compare starlight to vanilla or vice versa, you should be aware of the above - relighting chunks is always more expensive than loading them.
The performance of the vanilla engine is just awful. Existing modifications like Phosphor or Paper's light engine changes (some of Paper's changes include Phosphor's) fail to fix this issue.
Phosphor's changes to the existing light engine are very good, but there's only so much that can be done to vanilla's code to improve performance.
Paper also suffers from the same issue as Phosphor, as they also opt for changing vanilla code. However, Paper's changes have some technical problems that result in lighting broken lighting. See https://i.imgur.com/bK38jgS.png. For reference, this is what it should look like (generated via starlight): https://i.imgur.com/VND58Yr.jpg
Could these technical issues be fixed? Maybe, nobody knows what exactly is causing the issue, and when the vanilla light engine is overcomplicated debugging it was such a mess that everyone working on it gave up. Paper's changes also don't even target obvious issues with the light engine...
Effectively, it's really hard to fix the performance of the light engine by editing it - it's such a catastrophe it's better off burning it to the ground and starting anew.