Skip to content

Commit

Permalink
State all known limitations of right-associative extension methods (#…
Browse files Browse the repository at this point in the history
…19210)

[skip test]
[skip test_windows_fast]
[skip test_sbt]
[skip community_build]
[skip mima]
  • Loading branch information
bishabosha authored Dec 12, 2023
2 parents bdeb05a + 3647acf commit 97e4401
Showing 1 changed file with 33 additions and 1 deletion.
Original file line number Diff line number Diff line change
Expand Up @@ -61,4 +61,36 @@ For instance, the `+::` method above would become
This expansion has to be kept in mind when writing right-associative extension
methods with inter-parameter dependencies.

An overall simpler design could be obtained if right-associative operators could _only_ be defined as extension methods, and would be disallowed as normal methods. In that case neither arguments nor parameters would have to be swapped. Future versions of Scala should strive to achieve this simplification.
This expansion also introduces some inconsistencies when calling the extension methods in non infix form. The user needs to invert the order of the arguments at call site manually. For instance:

```scala
extension [T](x: T)
def *:(xs: List[T]): List[T] = ...

y.*:(ys) // error when following the parameter definition order
ys.*:(y)

*:(y)(ys) // error when following the parameter definition order
*:(ys)(y)
```

Another limitation of this representation is that it is impossible to pass the
type parameters of the `def` explicitly, (unless called in prefix form). For instance:

```scala
extension (x: Int)
def *:[T](xs: List[T]): List[T] = ...

xs.*:[Int](1) // error when trying to set T explicitly
```

The expansion of right-associative extension methods also affects the order in which contextual parameters can be passed explicitly.

Group extension can also behave unintuitively, in general all extension in a
group are extension on the receiver. Except if one of these extensions is a
right-associative extension method, in which case that one is an extension on the type of its argument. For instance:
```scala
extension (a: Int)
def :+(b: Long): Long = ... // extension on Int
def +:(b: Long): Long = ... // extension on Long
```

0 comments on commit 97e4401

Please sign in to comment.