Skip to content

Commit

Permalink
Post updates (failed try at GitHub Codespaces)
Browse files Browse the repository at this point in the history
  • Loading branch information
gerwitz committed Sep 1, 2023
1 parent 5b3f510 commit 02f03f5
Showing 1 changed file with 6 additions and 6 deletions.
12 changes: 6 additions & 6 deletions src/writing/2023/2023-08-17-culture-war.md
Original file line number Diff line number Diff line change
Expand Up @@ -18,18 +18,18 @@ But I also lamented that this email chain was fueled by the US culture war and s

For some time, now, the US political system asks everyone to subscribe to Red or Blue, inherit _all_ of the positions for their chosen team, and look for controversy in every possible issue.

Maybe you've chosen Red because you believe life begins at conception, so a pregnant woman's choice is a form of murder.
Maybe you've chosen Red because you believe life begins at conception, so ending a pregnancy is not only a matter of health choices. Even if you don't go so far as to believe fetuses have rights or any termination is akin to murder.

Maybe you understand democracy to be sustainable only with unlimited freedom of speech, and any constraint is a slippery slope to authoritarianism (by the wrong authorities). Or you're simply fed up with being told that everything about your culture is oppressive to somebody else.
Maybe you understand democracy to be sustainable only with unlimited freedom of speech, and any constraint is a slippery slope to authoritarianism (by the wrong authorities). Or you're simply fed up with being told that everything about your culture is oppressive to somebody else. Even if you don't believe inciting violence or hate is acceptable.

Maybe you see every social issue as fundamentally economic, and so financial self-determination is the one freedom we should not compromise. You might think the welfare state only holds back the very people it purports to lift.
Maybe you see every social issue as fundamentally economic, and so financial self-determination is the one freedom we should not compromise. You might think the welfare state only holds back the very people it purports to lift. Even if you believe government does have an important role to play in assuring a basic quality of life for all citizens.

Maybe you think we can reduce violent crime by putting more firearms into private hands.
Maybe you think we can reduce violent crime by putting more firearms into private hands. Even if you acknowledge the need to screen and train who carries, and where.

Maybe you're simply disgusted by people not subscribing to the gender or other identity norms you understand to hold our fragile society together.
Maybe you're simply disgusted by people not subscribing to the gender or other identity norms you understand to hold our fragile society together. Even if you don't deny that well-informed adults should be able to choose their own lifestyle.

Maybe it makes me too Blue that none of those ideas motivate me. But I can imagine them being reasonably held in good faith, so we ought to be able to have a civil discussion over them.

Why, though, should it be that if you find any of those issues credible, you are expected to believe in every single one of the others? Or think that Vladimir Putin is anything more than a tyrant? Or that the overwhelming preponderance of qualified experts and decades of observation which support the safe efficacy of vaccines are, actually, a cabal of malicious conspiracists? Or that every misguided, click-baiting media story which conflates weather and climate is evidence that actual scientists have some hidden agenda to deny us the conveniences of modern life?
Why, though, should it be that if you find any of those issues credible, you are expected to support the extreme version and also every single one of the others? Or think that Vladimir Putin is anything more than a tyrant? Or that the overwhelming preponderance of qualified experts and decades of observation which support the safe efficacy of vaccines are, actually, a cabal of malicious conspiracists? Or that every misguided, click-baiting media story which conflates weather and climate is evidence that actual scientists have some hidden agenda to deny us the conveniences of modern life?

Having removed myself some distance from it, I could almost find it funny if it didn't threaten my relationships or the stability of the planet we share.

0 comments on commit 02f03f5

Please sign in to comment.