Skip to content

User Privileges

Monica Cellio edited this page Jul 30, 2020 · 17 revisions

Status: deprecated.

Tracking spreadsheet by tl here.

Codidact will have a system of trust levels for user actions. These trust levels are based on specific site activity, not achieving specific reputation scores.

Numbers shown in bold are the defaults for full, active sites. We will also support a scaling factor for "small" or "new" sites, so privileges are achievable.

All changes to trust levels are logged.

Trust Level 0

This is the level of trust for brand new users. Not MVP: Contains a "new contributor" label.

  • May post 3 questions per day, but no more often than one every 60 minutes.
  • May post any number of answers, but no more often than one every 15 minutes.
  • May comment infinitely on own questions/answers.
  • May upvote answers to own questions.
  • May flag answers and comments on their posts, but have no more than 3 pending flags in two days.

(See these suggestions on messaging about rate limits.)

Trust Level 1

A level of trust for new members.

Requirements:

  • At least 1 well-received (Wilson score above 0.5) question or answer.

New Perks:

  • May post N questions per day, where N is the number of well-received questions or answers already posted, but at least 5. (Set a minimum so there's an increase from the previous level.)
  • May upvote.
  • May suggest edits.
  • May suggest duplicates.
  • May raise flags anywhere.
  • May post up to 10 comments per day on other people's questions/answers.

Trust Level 2

The standard level of trust for most users on the site.

Requirements:

  • At least 5 well-received questions/answers.

New Perks:

  • Question/answer/comment count restrictions are removed.
  • May downvote.

Trust Level 3

The first level of moderation, intended for experienced users who are ready to do more curation.

Requirements:

  • At least 50 accepted flags.
  • At least 50 accepted edits.
  • At least 15 well-received questions/answers.

There was discussion somewhere of an either/or approach to flags and edits, but I can't find it right now.

New Perks:

  • May vote-to-close directly, rather than simply flagging.
  • May edit directly, without review.
  • May review suggested edits and flags.
  • May create tags.
  • Not MVP: May protect posts from being answered by any TL0s.

Trust Level 4 - Deputy

This level adds moderation capabilities.

Requirements:

  • At least 250 successful reviews completed, with at least two categories having at least 50 each.

New Perks:

  • May temporarily lock posts.
  • May soft-delete posts.

Trust Level 5 - Moderator

Full moderators receive trust level 5, but may lose it upon becoming inactive.

Requirements:

  • Voted in by community. (can be voted out again by community)
  • Vetting by all current moderators.

New Perks:

  • Not MVP: May permanently lock posts.
  • May soft-delete comments.
  • May suspend specific permissions for users.
  • May send private messages to users.
  • May annotate users (to record information relevant for future moderation decisions).
  • May view private messages and annotations.
  • Has access to all moderation tools that we come up with in the future.

Trust Level 6 - Instance Administrator

This is the only trust level not based on site-specific activity. It is granted to instance-level administrators when needed to carry out actions that cannot be (or are not being) carried outre by site moderators. It is not a permanent trust level; instance-level admins are "regular" users most of the time.

  • May adjust Trust Levels of all TL2-5s.