amino: impl legacy msg to support eip-712 #113
Conversation
WalkthroughThe recent changes enhance the Changes
Sequence Diagram(s)sequenceDiagram
participant User
participant SDK
participant Module
User->>Module: Send Message
Module->>SDK: Validate Message
SDK-->>Module: Validation Result
Module->>SDK: Serialize Message with Amino Codec
SDK-->>User: Acknowledgment
Poem
Thank you for using CodeRabbit. We offer it for free to the OSS community and would appreciate your support in helping us grow. If you find it useful, would you consider giving us a shout-out on your favorite social media? TipsChatThere are 3 ways to chat with CodeRabbit:
Note: Be mindful of the bot's finite context window. It's strongly recommended to break down tasks such as reading entire modules into smaller chunks. For a focused discussion, use review comments to chat about specific files and their changes, instead of using the PR comments. CodeRabbit Commands (invoked as PR comments)
Additionally, you can add CodeRabbit Configuration File (
|
![coderabbitai[bot]](https://avatars.githubusercontent.com/in/347564?s=60&v=4){kind=small}
There was a problem hiding this comment.
Actionable comments posted: 1
Outside diff range, codebase verification and nitpick comments (8)
x/bnblightclient/types/msg.go (1)
41-43: Mismatch inTypemethod forMsgUpdateHeader.The
Typemethod forMsgUpdateHeaderincorrectly returns"lorenzo/bnblightclient/MsgUploadHeaders", which is intended for a different message type. This should be corrected to reflect the proper message type forMsgUpdateHeader.
- Update the
Typemethod inx/bnblightclient/types/msg.goto return the correct message type identifier forMsgUpdateHeader.Analysis chain
Implement
TypeforMsgUpdateHeader.The method returns the type identifier
"lorenzo/bnblightclient/MsgUploadHeaders". Verify that this matches the intended message type.Scripts executed
The following scripts were executed for the analysis:
Script:
#!/bin/bash # Description: Verify the Type method for MsgUpdateHeader. # Test: Check for consistency in type identifiers. Expect: Consistent usage of "lorenzo/bnblightclient/MsgUploadHeaders". rg --type go -A 3 'MsgUploadHeaders'Length of output: 15334
x/bnblightclient/types/codec.go (1)
22-26: Mismatch in message type identifiersThe identifiers for
MsgUpdateHeaderandMsgUploadHeadersare swapped in theRegisterLegacyAminoCodecfunction. Please correct the identifiers to match the intended message types.
MsgUpdateHeadershould be registered with"lorenzo/bnblightclient/MsgUpdateHeader".MsgUploadHeadersshould be registered with"lorenzo/bnblightclient/MsgUploadHeaders".Analysis chain
Register concrete message types with codec.
The
RegisterLegacyAminoCodecfunction registersMsgUpdateHeader,MsgUploadHeaders, andMsgUpdateParamswith appropriate identifiers. Verify that the identifiers match the intended message types.Scripts executed
The following scripts were executed for the analysis:
Script:
#!/bin/bash # Description: Verify the registration of message types with the codec. # Test: Check for consistency in message type registration. Expect: Correct identifiers for each message type. rg --type go -A 3 'RegisterConcrete'Length of output: 4677
x/btcstaking/types/msg.go (6)
67-69: Consider providing a non-empty route forMsgCreateBTCStaking.The
Routemethod currently returns an empty string. Consider specifying a route if this message should be routed through specific handlers.- return "" + return "btcstaking"
112-114: Consider providing a non-empty route forMsgBurnRequest.The
Routemethod currently returns an empty string. Consider specifying a route if this message should be routed through specific handlers.- return "" + return "btcstaking"
147-149: Consider providing a non-empty route forMsgUpdateParams.The
Routemethod currently returns an empty string. Consider specifying a route if this message should be routed through specific handlers.- return "" + return "btcstaking"
181-183: Consider providing a non-empty route forMsgCreateBTCBStaking.The
Routemethod currently returns an empty string. Consider specifying a route if this message should be routed through specific handlers.- return "" + return "btcstaking"
208-210: Consider providing a non-empty route forMsgAddReceiver.The
Routemethod currently returns an empty string. Consider specifying a route if this message should be routed through specific handlers.- return "" + return "btcstaking"
235-237: Consider providing a non-empty route forMsgRemoveReceiver.The
Routemethod currently returns an empty string. Consider specifying a route if this message should be routed through specific handlers.- return "" + return "btcstaking"
Review details
Configuration used: CodeRabbit UI
Review profile: CHILL
Files ignored due to path filters (7)
x/agent/types/tx.pb.gois excluded by!**/*.pb.gox/bnblightclient/types/tx.pb.gois excluded by!**/*.pb.gox/btclightclient/types/tx.pb.gois excluded by!**/*.pb.gox/btcstaking/types/tx.pb.gois excluded by!**/*.pb.gox/fee/types/tx.pb.gois excluded by!**/*.pb.gox/plan/types/tx.pb.gois excluded by!**/*.pb.gox/token/types/tx.pb.gois excluded by!**/*.pb.go
Files selected for processing (28)
- proto/lorenzo/agent/v1/tx.proto (5 hunks)
- proto/lorenzo/bnblightclient/v1/tx.proto (4 hunks)
- proto/lorenzo/btclightclient/v1/tx.proto (4 hunks)
- proto/lorenzo/btcstaking/v1/tx.proto (7 hunks)
- proto/lorenzo/fee/v1/tx.proto (2 hunks)
- proto/lorenzo/plan/v1/tx.proto (10 hunks)
- proto/lorenzo/token/v1/tx.proto (7 hunks)
- x/agent/module.go (1 hunks)
- x/agent/types/codec.go (2 hunks)
- x/agent/types/msg.go (6 hunks)
- x/bnblightclient/module.go (1 hunks)
- x/bnblightclient/types/codec.go (1 hunks)
- x/bnblightclient/types/msg.go (5 hunks)
- x/btclightclient/module.go (1 hunks)
- x/btclightclient/types/codec.go (2 hunks)
- x/btclightclient/types/msgs.go (5 hunks)
- x/btcstaking/module.go (1 hunks)
- x/btcstaking/types/codec.go (1 hunks)
- x/btcstaking/types/msg.go (9 hunks)
- x/fee/module.go (1 hunks)
- x/fee/types/codec.go (1 hunks)
- x/fee/types/msgs.go (2 hunks)
- x/plan/module.go (1 hunks)
- x/plan/types/codec.go (1 hunks)
- x/plan/types/msg.go (11 hunks)
- x/token/module.go (1 hunks)
- x/token/types/codec.go (1 hunks)
- x/token/types/msg.go (6 hunks)
Additional comments not posted (158)
x/fee/types/codec.go (3)
10-13: Initialize and use Amino codec correctly.The
aminoandAminoCdcvariables are initialized correctly, allowing for legacy serialization. This setup supports backward compatibility with existing message types.
19-21: Register concrete message types for Amino codec.The
RegisterLegacyAminoCodecfunction correctly registersMsgUpdateParamswith the codec, ensuring it can be serialized and deserialized using Amino.
15-17: Ensure init function registers all necessary types.The
initfunction ensures thatRegisterLegacyAminoCodecis called during package initialization. Verify that all message types that require legacy Amino serialization are registered here.Verification successful
All necessary message types are properly registered.
The
initfunction inx/fee/types/codec.gocorrectly registers all necessary message types for legacy Amino serialization. Specifically,MsgUpdateParamsis registered, and no other message types in thefeemodule require registration.Scripts executed
The following scripts were executed for the analysis:
Script:
#!/bin/bash # Description: Verify all necessary message types are registered in the init function. # Test: Search for the usage of RegisterLegacyAminoCodec to ensure all message types are registered. rg --type go 'RegisterLegacyAminoCodec' -A 3Length of output: 7396
Script:
#!/bin/bash # Search for all message types in the fee module to ensure they are registered with the codec. rg --type go 'type Msg' -A 3 x/feeLength of output: 1142
x/btclightclient/types/codec.go (3)
10-13: Initialize and use Amino codec correctly.The
aminoandAminoCdcvariables are initialized correctly, facilitating legacy serialization for thebtclightclientmodule.
19-22: Register concrete message types for Amino codec.The
RegisterLegacyAminoCodecfunction correctly registers multiple message types, ensuring compatibility with Amino serialization.
15-17: Ensure init function registers all necessary types.The
initfunction ensuresRegisterLegacyAminoCodecis invoked during package initialization. Confirm that all relevant message types are registered.Verification successful
All necessary message types are registered in the
initfunction.The
initfunction inx/btclightclient/types/codec.gocallsRegisterLegacyAminoCodec, which registers the message typesMsgInsertHeaders,MsgUpdateParams, andMsgUpdateFeeRate. This ensures that all relevant types are registered during package initialization.Scripts executed
The following scripts were executed for the analysis:
Script:
#!/bin/bash # Description: Verify all necessary message types are registered in the init function. # Test: Search for the usage of RegisterLegacyAminoCodec to ensure all message types are registered. rg --type go 'RegisterLegacyAminoCodec' -A 3Length of output: 7396
x/agent/types/codec.go (4)
10-13: Initialize and use Amino codec correctly.The
aminoandAminoCdcvariables are initialized correctly, supporting legacy serialization for theagentmodule.
19-24: Register concrete message types for Amino codec.The
RegisterLegacyAminoCodecfunction correctly registers multiple message types, ensuring compatibility with Amino serialization.
35-35: Update RegisterInterfaces to include all message types.The
RegisterInterfacesfunction now includesMsgUpdateParams, ensuring it is registered in the interface registry. This is important for proper message handling.
15-17: Ensure init function registers all necessary types.The
initfunction ensuresRegisterLegacyAminoCodecis invoked during package initialization. Verify that all relevant message types are registered.Verification successful
All necessary message types are registered in the init function
The
initfunction inx/agent/types/codec.gocorrectly registers all relevant message types for the agent module usingRegisterLegacyAminoCodec. No further action is required.Scripts executed
The following scripts were executed for the analysis:
Script:
#!/bin/bash # Description: Verify all necessary message types are registered in the init function. # Test: Search for the usage of RegisterLegacyAminoCodec to ensure all message types are registered. rg --type go 'RegisterLegacyAminoCodec' -A 3Length of output: 7396
proto/lorenzo/fee/v1/tx.proto (2)
7-7: Import amino.proto for Amino serialization.The import of
amino/amino.protois necessary for enabling Amino encoding options within this proto file.
23-23: Add Amino name option for MsgUpdateParams.The addition of
option (amino.name) = "lorenzo/fee/MsgUpdateParams"ensures the message is correctly identified and serialized using Amino, enhancing compatibility within the Cosmos ecosystem.x/token/types/codec.go (3)
10-13: Initialize Amino codec correctly.The initialization of the
aminoandAminoCdcvariables is correct. This setup is essential for handling legacy Amino serialization.
15-17: Ensure proper registration of legacy Amino codec.The
initfunction ensures that the legacy Amino codec is registered upon package initialization. This is a good practice for ensuring the codec is ready for use.
19-25: Register message types with unique identifiers.The
RegisterLegacyAminoCodecfunction registers several message types with unique string identifiers. Ensure that these identifiers are consistent with the rest of the application to avoid conflicts.x/btcstaking/types/codec.go (2)
10-13: Initialize Amino codec correctly.The initialization of the
aminoandAminoCdcvariables is correct. This setup is essential for handling legacy Amino serialization.
15-17: Ensure proper registration of legacy Amino codec.The
initfunction ensures that the legacy Amino codec is registered upon package initialization. This is a good practice for ensuring the codec is ready for use.x/plan/types/codec.go (3)
10-13: Initialize Amino codec correctly.The initialization of the
aminoandAminoCdcvariables is correct. This setup is essential for handling legacy Amino serialization.
15-17: Ensure proper registration of legacy Amino codec.The
initfunction ensures that the legacy Amino codec is registered upon package initialization. This is a good practice for ensuring the codec is ready for use.
19-29: Register message types with unique identifiers.The
RegisterLegacyAminoCodecfunction registers several message types with unique string identifiers. Ensure that these identifiers are consistent with the rest of the application to avoid conflicts.Verification successful
Identifiers are unique across the codebase.
The registered message type identifiers in the
RegisterLegacyAminoCodecfunction are unique, as verified by the script execution. No duplicates were found, indicating consistency within the application.Scripts executed
The following scripts were executed for the analysis:
Script:
#!/bin/bash # Description: Verify that the registered message type identifiers are unique across the codebase. # Test: Search for message type identifiers. Expect: Unique identifiers. rg --type go -A 0 'cdc.RegisterConcrete' | awk -F'"' '{print $2}' | sort | uniq -dLength of output: 82
Script:
#!/bin/bash # Re-run the check for unique message type identifiers with improved diagnostics. # Search for message type identifiers registered with cdc.RegisterConcrete and check for duplicates. rg --type go 'cdc.RegisterConcrete' | awk -F'"' '{print $2}' | sort | uniq -dLength of output: 77
x/fee/types/msgs.go (4)
10-13: Implement interfaces correctly forMsgUpdateParams.The implementation of both
sdk.Msgandlegacytx.LegacyMsginterfaces forMsgUpdateParamsensures compatibility with the Cosmos SDK.
29-31: Ensure JSON serialization is correct inGetSignBytes.The
GetSignBytesmethod usesAminoCdcfor JSON serialization. Verify thatAminoCdcis correctly initialized and used throughout the codebase.Verification successful
JSON Serialization with
AminoCdcis Correctly ImplementedThe
AminoCdccodec is consistently initialized and used for JSON serialization across the codebase, including in theGetSignBytesmethod. No issues found with its setup or usage.Scripts executed
The following scripts were executed for the analysis:
Script:
#!/bin/bash # Description: Verify that `AminoCdc` is correctly initialized and used for serialization. # Test: Search for `AminoCdc` initialization and usage. Expect: Correct setup and usage. rg --type go -A 5 'AminoCdc'Length of output: 10587
37-39: Ensure message type identifier consistency inType.The
Typemethod provides a unique identifier for the message. Verify that this identifier is used consistently across the codebase.Verification successful
Message Type Identifier Consistency Verified
The message type identifier "lorenzo/fee/MsgUpdateParams" is used consistently across the codebase in the following locations:
x/fee/types/msgs.go: In theTypemethod.x/fee/types/codec.go: In theRegisterConcretefunction.proto/lorenzo/fee/v1/tx.proto: As an option in the protocol buffer.No inconsistencies were found.
Scripts executed
The following scripts were executed for the analysis:
Script:
#!/bin/bash # Description: Verify the consistency of message type identifiers. # Test: Search for `lorenzo/fee/MsgUpdateParams` usage. Expect: Consistent usage. rg --type go -A 0 'lorenzo/fee/MsgUpdateParams'Length of output: 204
Script:
#!/bin/bash # Broader search for any usage of the message type identifier across the codebase. rg 'lorenzo/fee/MsgUpdateParams'Length of output: 274
33-35: Clarify the routing logic inRoute.The
Routemethod returns an empty string, which is typical for messages without a specific routing path. Ensure this is intentional and aligns with the application's routing logic.Verification successful
Consistent Use of Empty String in
RouteMethodThe
Routemethod consistently returns an empty string across multiple modules, suggesting this is an intentional design choice. While no explicit documentation or comments were found to explain this, the pattern appears deliberate and likely relies on other mechanisms for routing. Ensure this aligns with your application's architecture and requirements.Scripts executed
The following scripts were executed for the analysis:
Script:
#!/bin/bash # Description: Verify the routing logic for `MsgUpdateParams`. # Test: Search for `Route` method usage and documentation. Expect: Alignment with routing logic. rg --type go -A 5 'func \(m \*MsgUpdateParams\) Route\(\)'Length of output: 1860
Script:
#!/bin/bash # Search for documentation or comments explaining the use of empty string in Route methods. rg --type go 'Route() string' -A 10 | grep -i 'route\|empty'Length of output: 148
proto/lorenzo/btclightclient/v1/tx.proto (4)
7-7: Add import foramino.proto.The import statement for
amino/amino.protois necessary to support theamino.nameoptions added to the message definitions. This is a correct addition.
29-29: Addamino.nameoption toMsgInsertHeaders.The addition of
(amino.name) = "lorenzo/btclightclient/MsgInsertHeaders"enhances the serialization metadata for theMsgInsertHeadersmessage. This change is correct and aligns with the Cosmos SDK's usage of Amino encoding.
44-44: Addamino.nameoption toMsgUpdateParams.The addition of
(amino.name) = "lorenzo/btclightclient/MsgUpdateParams"is appropriate for improving the serialization context of theMsgUpdateParamsmessage. This is a correct enhancement.
63-63: Addamino.nameoption toMsgUpdateFeeRate.The inclusion of
(amino.name) = "lorenzo/btclightclient/MsgUpdateFeeRate"provides additional serialization metadata for theMsgUpdateFeeRatemessage. This addition is correct and beneficial for interoperability.x/bnblightclient/types/msg.go (9)
15-18: Implementlegacytx.LegacyMsginterface.The addition of these lines ensures that
MsgUpdateHeader,MsgUploadHeaders, andMsgUpdateParamsimplement thelegacytx.LegacyMsginterface. This is a necessary step for supporting legacy transaction handling.
33-35: ImplementGetSignBytesforMsgUpdateHeader.The method correctly serializes the message into JSON format for signing. The use of
sdk.MustSortJSONandAminoCdc.MustMarshalJSONensures proper serialization.
58-60: ImplementGetSignBytesforMsgUploadHeaders.This method is correctly implemented to serialize the message for signing. It uses
sdk.MustSortJSONandAminoCdc.MustMarshalJSONfor proper serialization.
62-64: ImplementRouteforMsgUploadHeaders.The method returns an empty string, similar to
MsgUpdateHeader. Ensure this aligns with the design requirements.
66-68: ImplementTypeforMsgUploadHeaders.The method returns
"lorenzo/bnblightclient/MsgUpdateHeader". Verify the correctness of this type identifier.
83-85: ImplementGetSignBytesforMsgUpdateParams.The method correctly serializes the message into JSON format for signing. The use of
sdk.MustSortJSONandAminoCdc.MustMarshalJSONensures proper serialization.
87-89: ImplementRouteforMsgUpdateParams.The method returns an empty string, indicating no specific routing logic is defined. Ensure that this behavior aligns with the intended design.
91-93: ImplementTypeforMsgUpdateParams.The method returns the type identifier
"lorenzo/bnblightclient/MsgUpdateParams". Verify that this matches the intended message type.
37-39: ImplementRouteforMsgUpdateHeader.The method returns an empty string, indicating no specific routing logic is defined. Ensure that this behavior aligns with the intended design.
x/bnblightclient/types/codec.go (2)
14-16: Initialize codec instances for legacy amino encoding.The initialization of
aminoandAminoCdcis correct and necessary for handling legacy amino encoding.
18-20: Register legacy amino codec ininitfunction.The
initfunction ensures that the codec is registered upon package initialization. This is a standard practice for codec registration.proto/lorenzo/bnblightclient/v1/tx.proto (4)
7-7: Add import foramino.proto.The import statement for
amino/amino.protois necessary to support theamino.nameoptions added to the message definitions. This is a correct addition.
31-31: Addamino.nameoption toMsgUploadHeaders.The addition of
(amino.name) = "lorenzo/bnblightclient/MsgUploadHeaders"enhances the serialization metadata for theMsgUploadHeadersmessage. This change is correct and aligns with the Cosmos SDK's usage of Amino encoding.
42-42: Addamino.nameoption toMsgUpdateHeader.The inclusion of
(amino.name) = "lorenzo/bnblightclient/MsgUpdateHeader"provides additional serialization metadata for theMsgUpdateHeadermessage. This addition is correct and beneficial for interoperability.
55-55: Addamino.nameoption toMsgUpdateParams.The addition of
(amino.name) = "lorenzo/bnblightclient/MsgUpdateParams"is appropriate for improving the serialization context of theMsgUpdateParamsmessage. This is a correct enhancement.proto/lorenzo/btcstaking/v1/tx.proto (7)
7-7: Importamino.protois necessary foramino.nameoptions.The addition of this import is essential for enabling the
amino.nameoptions in the message definitions.
58-59: Addamino.nametoMsgCreateBTCStaking.The addition of the
amino.nameoption enhances the message's identity for serialization purposes.
71-71: Addamino.nametoMsgCreateBTCBStaking.The
amino.nameoption is added to improve serialization clarity.
83-84: Addamino.nametoMsgBurnRequest.Including the
amino.nameoption ensures proper recognition in the Amino serialization framework.
97-97: Addamino.nametoMsgAddReceiver.The
amino.nameoption is added to facilitate correct serialization.
107-107: Addamino.nametoMsgRemoveReceiver.The
amino.nameoption enhances message identification for serialization.
116-116: Addamino.nametoMsgUpdateParams.The
amino.nameoption is crucial for serialization in the Amino protocol.proto/lorenzo/agent/v1/tx.proto (5)
7-7: Importamino.protois necessary foramino.nameoptions.This import is essential for the new
amino.nameoptions to function correctly.
31-31: Addamino.nametoMsgUpdateParams.The
amino.nameoption improves the message's serialization identity.
49-49: Addamino.nametoMsgAddAgent.The
amino.nameoption is added to enhance serialization clarity.
74-74: Addamino.nametoMsgEditAgent.Including the
amino.nameoption ensures proper serialization recognition.
94-94: Addamino.nametoMsgRemoveAgent.The
amino.nameoption facilitates correct serialization.x/token/module.go (1)
42-44: ImplementRegisterLegacyAminoCodecto register the codec.The method now properly registers the legacy amino codec, enhancing the module's interoperability.
x/agent/types/msg.go (10)
10-11: Add import forlegacytx.This import is necessary for implementing the
legacytx.LegacyMsginterface.
21-26: Add type assertions forlegacytx.LegacyMsg.These assertions ensure that the message types implement the
legacytx.LegacyMsginterface, enhancing compatibility.
42-44: ImplementGetSignBytesforMsgUpdateParams.This method serializes the message for signing, ensuring correct signature generation.
46-49: ImplementRouteandTypeforMsgUpdateParams.These methods define the routing path and type identifier, essential for message handling.
77-79: ImplementGetSignBytesforMsgAddAgent.This method ensures the message is correctly serialized for signing.
81-84: ImplementRouteandTypeforMsgAddAgent.These methods are crucial for defining the message's routing and type.
104-106: ImplementGetSignBytesforMsgEditAgent.This method serializes the message for signing, ensuring signature correctness.
108-111: ImplementRouteandTypeforMsgEditAgent.These methods define the routing path and type identifier, essential for message processing.
130-132: ImplementGetSignBytesforMsgRemoveAgent.This method ensures the message is serialized correctly for signing.
134-136: ImplementRouteandTypeforMsgRemoveAgent.These methods are necessary for defining the message's routing and type.
proto/lorenzo/token/v1/tx.proto (6)
35-35: Ensure consistency in amino names.The addition of
amino.nameoptions is correct. Ensure that these names are consistent with any existing naming conventions across the codebase.
50-50: Ensure consistency in amino names.The addition of
amino.nameoptions is correct. Ensure that these names are consistent with any existing naming conventions across the codebase.
64-64: Ensure consistency in amino names.The addition of
amino.nameoptions is correct. Ensure that these names are consistent with any existing naming conventions across the codebase.
76-76: Ensure consistency in amino names.The addition of
amino.nameoptions is correct. Ensure that these names are consistent with any existing naming conventions across the codebase.
90-90: Ensure consistency in amino names.The addition of
amino.nameoptions is correct. Ensure that these names are consistent with any existing naming conventions across the codebase.
110-110: Ensure consistency in amino names.The addition of
amino.nameoptions is correct. Ensure that these names are consistent with any existing naming conventions across the codebase.x/btclightclient/types/msgs.go (10)
19-23: Implementations oflegacytx.LegacyMsgare correct.The declarations ensure that the message types implement the
legacytx.LegacyMsginterface. This is crucial for backward compatibility.
106-108: Correct implementation ofGetSignBytes.The
GetSignBytesmethod correctly serializes the message for signing. EnsureAminoCdcis properly configured elsewhere in the codebase.
110-110: Clarify theRoutemethod's return value.The
Routemethod returns an empty string, which might be a placeholder. Ensure this is intentional and documented.
112-112: Correct implementation ofType.The
Typemethod provides a specific identifier for the message, aiding in transaction processing.
135-137: Correct implementation ofGetSignBytes.The
GetSignBytesmethod correctly serializes the message for signing. EnsureAminoCdcis properly configured elsewhere in the codebase.
139-139: Clarify theRoutemethod's return value.The
Routemethod returns an empty string, which might be a placeholder. Ensure this is intentional and documented.
141-141: Correct implementation ofType.The
Typemethod provides a specific identifier for the message, aiding in transaction processing.
158-160: Correct implementation ofGetSignBytes.The
GetSignBytesmethod correctly serializes the message for signing. EnsureAminoCdcis properly configured elsewhere in the codebase.
162-162: Clarify theRoutemethod's return value.The
Routemethod returns an empty string, which might be a placeholder. Ensure this is intentional and documented.
164-164: Correct implementation ofType.The
Typemethod provides a specific identifier for the message, aiding in transaction processing.x/agent/module.go (1)
55-57: Correct implementation ofRegisterLegacyAminoCodec.The method now registers the module's types with the codec, enhancing serialization support.
x/fee/module.go (1)
55-57: Correct implementation ofRegisterLegacyAminoCodec.The method now registers the module's types with the codec, enhancing serialization support.
x/btclightclient/module.go (1)
48-48: Correct implementation ofRegisterLegacyAminoCodec.The
RegisterLegacyAminoCodecfunction correctly registers the module's types with the provided codec. This aligns with the shift towards supporting legacy message formats.x/bnblightclient/module.go (1)
55-57: Implementation ofRegisterLegacyAminoCodecis correct.The function now registers the module's types, which is essential for proper serialization and deserialization. This enhancement improves the module's interoperability with the codec system.
x/plan/module.go (1)
55-57: Correct implementation ofRegisterLegacyAminoCodec.The function now registers the module's types with the codec, ensuring proper serialization and deserialization. This aligns with the intended enhancements.
x/btcstaking/types/msg.go (13)
26-33: Ensure compatibility withlegacytx.LegacyMsg.The declaration ensures that the message types implement the
legacytx.LegacyMsginterface, which is crucial for backward compatibility. This is a necessary step for integrating with legacy transaction formats.
63-65: Correct implementation ofGetSignBytesforMsgCreateBTCStaking.The method correctly serializes the message for signing, using the Amino codec. This is essential for ensuring the message can be signed and verified.
71-73: CorrectTypeimplementation forMsgCreateBTCStaking.The method returns the correct type string, which is necessary for message processing within the Cosmos SDK.
108-110: Correct implementation ofGetSignBytesforMsgBurnRequest.The method correctly serializes the message for signing, ensuring compatibility with the legacy transaction format.
116-118: CorrectTypeimplementation forMsgBurnRequest.The method returns the correct type string, facilitating proper message processing.
143-145: Correct implementation ofGetSignBytesforMsgUpdateParams.The method serializes the message for signing, ensuring it adheres to the expected format for legacy transactions.
151-153: CorrectTypeimplementation forMsgUpdateParams.The method provides the correct type string, which is essential for message identification and processing.
177-179: Correct implementation ofGetSignBytesforMsgCreateBTCBStaking.The method ensures the message is serialized correctly for signing, maintaining compatibility with legacy formats.
185-187: CorrectTypeimplementation forMsgCreateBTCBStaking.The method returns the correct type string, aiding in the message processing workflow.
204-206: Correct implementation ofGetSignBytesforMsgAddReceiver.The method correctly serializes the message, ensuring it can be signed and verified within the legacy transaction framework.
212-214: CorrectTypeimplementation forMsgAddReceiver.The method provides the appropriate type string, necessary for message handling.
231-233: Correct implementation ofGetSignBytesforMsgRemoveReceiver.The method serializes the message for signing, adhering to the legacy transaction requirements.
239-241: CorrectTypeimplementation forMsgRemoveReceiver.The method returns the correct type string, facilitating proper message processing.
x/btcstaking/module.go (1)
55-55: Update to useRegisterLegacyAminoCodec.The method
RegisterLegacyAminoCodecnow usestypes.RegisterLegacyAminoCodec(cdc), which indicates a shift towards utilizing a legacy codec for amino marshaling and unmarshaling. This change may affect data serialization and deserialization within the module, potentially impacting compatibility with previously stored data or interactions with other modules relying on the amino codec.x/token/types/msg.go (18)
67-69: Implementation ofGetSignBytesforMsgRegisterCoin.The
GetSignBytesmethod correctly serializes the message into JSON format and sorts it, ensuring consistent signatures.
71-73: Implementation ofRouteforMsgRegisterCoin.The
Routemethod returns an empty string, indicating no specific routing path for this message type.
75-77: Implementation ofTypeforMsgRegisterCoin.The
Typemethod returns a unique identifier for the message type, which is essential for message processing.
113-115: Implementation ofGetSignBytesforMsgRegisterERC20.The
GetSignBytesmethod correctly serializes the message into JSON format and sorts it, ensuring consistent signatures.
117-119: Implementation ofRouteforMsgRegisterERC20.The
Routemethod returns an empty string, indicating no specific routing path for this message type.
121-123: Implementation ofTypeforMsgRegisterERC20.The
Typemethod returns a unique identifier for the message type, which is essential for message processing.
146-148: Implementation ofGetSignBytesforMsgToggleConversion.The
GetSignBytesmethod correctly serializes the message into JSON format and sorts it, ensuring consistent signatures.
150-152: Implementation ofRouteforMsgToggleConversion.The
Routemethod returns an empty string, indicating no specific routing path for this message type.
154-156: Implementation ofTypeforMsgToggleConversion.The
Typemethod returns a unique identifier for the message type, which is essential for message processing.
189-191: Implementation ofGetSignBytesforMsgConvertCoin.The
GetSignBytesmethod correctly serializes the message into JSON format and sorts it, ensuring consistent signatures.
193-195: Implementation ofRouteforMsgConvertCoin.The
Routemethod returns an empty string, indicating no specific routing path for this message type.
197-199: Implementation ofTypeforMsgConvertCoin.The
Typemethod returns a unique identifier for the message type, which is essential for message processing.
229-231: Implementation ofGetSignBytesforMsgConvertERC20.The
GetSignBytesmethod correctly serializes the message into JSON format and sorts it, ensuring consistent signatures.
233-235: Implementation ofRouteforMsgConvertERC20.The
Routemethod returns an empty string, indicating no specific routing path for this message type.
237-239: Implementation ofTypeforMsgConvertERC20.The
Typemethod returns a unique identifier for the message type, which is essential for message processing.
255-257: Implementation ofGetSignBytesforMsgUpdateParams.The
GetSignBytesmethod correctly serializes the message into JSON format and sorts it, ensuring consistent signatures.
259-261: Implementation ofRouteforMsgUpdateParams.The
Routemethod returns an empty string, indicating no specific routing path for this message type.
263-265: Implementation ofTypeforMsgUpdateParams.The
Typemethod returns a unique identifier for the message type, which is essential for message processing.proto/lorenzo/plan/v1/tx.proto (10)
7-7: Import ofamino.protofor Amino serialization.The import of
amino/amino.protoindicates a shift towards incorporating Amino serialization features into the message structures.
49-49: Addition ofamino.nameoption forMsgUpdateParams.The
amino.nameoption assigns a unique name for the message type in the Amino serialization format, enhancing interoperability.
67-67: Addition ofamino.nameoption forMsgUpgradePlan.The
amino.nameoption assigns a unique name for the message type in the Amino serialization format, enhancing interoperability.
84-84: Addition ofamino.nameoption forMsgCreatePlan.The
amino.nameoption assigns a unique name for the message type in the Amino serialization format, enhancing interoperability.
117-117: Addition ofamino.nameoption forMsgSetMerkleRoot.The
amino.nameoption assigns a unique name for the message type in the Amino serialization format, enhancing interoperability.
142-142: Addition ofamino.nameoption forMsgClaims.The
amino.nameoption assigns a unique name for the message type in the Amino serialization format, enhancing interoperability.
176-176: Addition ofamino.nameoption forMsgUpdatePlanStatus.The
amino.nameoption assigns a unique name for the message type in the Amino serialization format, enhancing interoperability.
195-195: Addition ofamino.nameoption forMsgCreateYAT.The
amino.nameoption assigns a unique name for the message type in the Amino serialization format, enhancing interoperability.
216-216: Addition ofamino.nameoption forMsgSetMinter.The
amino.nameoption assigns a unique name for the message type in the Amino serialization format, enhancing interoperability.
234-234: Addition ofamino.nameoption forMsgRemoveMinter.The
amino.nameoption assigns a unique name for the message type in the Amino serialization format, enhancing interoperability.x/plan/types/msg.go (29)
10-10: Import oflegacytxfor legacy message interfaces.The import of
legacytxindicates the file will now leverage legacy message interfaces, enhancing interoperability with the legacy transaction system.
26-36: Declaration of message types aslegacytx.LegacyMsg.The message types are now recognized as legacy messages, enhancing their interoperability with the legacy transaction system.
52-54: Implementation ofGetSignBytesforMsgUpdateParams.The
GetSignBytesmethod correctly serializes the message into JSON format and sorts it, ensuring consistent signatures.
56-58: Implementation ofRouteforMsgUpdateParams.The
Routemethod returns an empty string, indicating no specific routing path for this message type.
60-62: Implementation ofTypeforMsgUpdateParams.The
Typemethod returns a unique identifier for the message type, which is essential for message processing.
81-83: Implementation ofGetSignBytesforMsgUpgradePlan.The
GetSignBytesmethod correctly serializes the message into JSON format and sorts it, ensuring consistent signatures.
85-87: Implementation ofRouteforMsgUpgradePlan.The
Routemethod returns an empty string, indicating no specific routing path for this message type.
89-91: Implementation ofTypeforMsgUpgradePlan.The
Typemethod returns a unique identifier for the message type, which is essential for message processing.
122-124: Implementation ofGetSignBytesforMsgCreatePlan.The
GetSignBytesmethod correctly serializes the message into JSON format and sorts it, ensuring consistent signatures.
126-128: Implementation ofRouteforMsgCreatePlan.The
Routemethod returns an empty string, indicating no specific routing path for this message type.
130-132: Implementation ofTypeforMsgCreatePlan.The
Typemethod returns a unique identifier for the message type, which is essential for message processing.
169-171: Implementation ofGetSignBytesforMsgClaims.The
GetSignBytesmethod correctly serializes the message into JSON format and sorts it, ensuring consistent signatures.
173-175: Implementation ofRouteforMsgClaims.The
Routemethod returns an empty string, indicating no specific routing path for this message type.
177-179: Implementation ofTypeforMsgClaims.The
Typemethod returns a unique identifier for the message type, which is essential for message processing.
201-203: Implementation ofGetSignBytesforMsgCreateYAT.The
GetSignBytesmethod correctly serializes the message into JSON format and sorts it, ensuring consistent signatures.
205-207: Implementation ofRouteforMsgCreateYAT.The
Routemethod returns an empty string, indicating no specific routing path for this message type.
209-211: Implementation ofTypeforMsgCreateYAT.The
Typemethod returns a unique identifier for the message type, which is essential for message processing.
233-235: Implementation ofGetSignBytesforMsgUpdatePlanStatus.The
GetSignBytesmethod correctly serializes the message into JSON format and sorts it, ensuring consistent signatures.
237-239: Implementation ofRouteforMsgUpdatePlanStatus.The
Routemethod returns an empty string, indicating no specific routing path for this message type.
241-243: Implementation ofTypeforMsgUpdatePlanStatus.The
Typemethod returns a unique identifier for the message type, which is essential for message processing.
265-267: Implementation ofGetSignBytesforMsgSetMinter.The
GetSignBytesmethod correctly serializes the message into JSON format and sorts it, ensuring consistent signatures.
269-271: Implementation ofRouteforMsgSetMinter.The
Routemethod returns an empty string, indicating no specific routing path for this message type.
273-275: Implementation ofTypeforMsgSetMinter.The
Typemethod returns a unique identifier for the message type, which is essential for message processing.
297-299: Implementation ofGetSignBytesforMsgRemoveMinter.The
GetSignBytesmethod correctly serializes the message into JSON format and sorts it, ensuring consistent signatures.
301-303: Implementation ofRouteforMsgRemoveMinter.The
Routemethod returns an empty string, indicating no specific routing path for this message type.
305-307: Implementation ofTypeforMsgRemoveMinter.The
Typemethod returns a unique identifier for the message type, which is essential for message processing.
332-334: Implementation ofGetSignBytesforMsgSetMerkleRoot.The
GetSignBytesmethod correctly serializes the message into JSON format and sorts it, ensuring consistent signatures.
336-338: Implementation ofRouteforMsgSetMerkleRoot.The
Routemethod returns an empty string, indicating no specific routing path for this message type.
340-342: Implementation ofTypeforMsgSetMerkleRoot.The
Typemethod returns a unique identifier for the message type, which is essential for message processing.
There was a problem hiding this comment.
Actionable comments posted: 0
Review details
Configuration used: CodeRabbit UI
Review profile: CHILL
Files selected for processing (1)
- x/btcstaking/types/codec.go (1 hunks)
Additional comments not posted (4)
x/btcstaking/types/codec.go (4)
10-13: Initialization of codec variables is correct.The initialization of
aminoandAminoCdcis appropriate and follows standard practices for setting up legacy Amino codecs in the Cosmos SDK.
15-17: Use ofinitfunction for codec registration is appropriate.The
initfunction ensures that the codec registration occurs automatically, which is a common and effective pattern in Go packages.
Line range hint
28-38: Interface registration is correctly implemented.The
RegisterInterfacesfunction correctly registers the message types as implementations ofsdk.Msg, ensuring proper integration with the SDK's message handling.
19-25: Verify message identifiers for correctness.Ensure that the message identifiers for
MsgRemoveReceiverandMsgAddReceiverare correctly registered. Previous comments indicated they might be swapped.Run the following script to verify the correctness of message identifiers:
Verification successful
Let's correct the search pattern and try again to verify the message identifiers.
Let's adjust the search pattern to avoid special characters and focus on unique parts of the registration strings.
Message identifiers are correctly registered.
The message identifiers for
MsgRemoveReceiverandMsgAddReceiverare correctly registered with the expected paths in the codebase. No issues were found with these registrations.
MsgRemoveReceiveris registered as"lorenzo/btcstaking/MsgRemoveReceiver".MsgAddReceiveris registered as"lorenzo/btcstaking/MsgAddReceiver".Scripts executed
The following scripts were executed for the analysis:
Script:
#!/bin/bash # Description: Verify the correctness of message identifiers for MsgRemoveReceiver and MsgAddReceiver. # Test: Check for swapped identifiers. Expect: Correct registration paths. rg --type go $'RegisterConcrete(&MsgRemoveReceiver{}, "lorenzo/btcstaking/MsgRemoveReceiver", nil)' rg --type go $'RegisterConcrete(&MsgAddReceiver{}, "lorenzo/btcstaking/MsgAddReceiver", nil)'Length of output: 590
Script:
#!/bin/bash # Description: Verify the correctness of message identifiers for MsgRemoveReceiver and MsgAddReceiver. # Test: Check for swapped identifiers. Expect: Correct registration paths. rg --type go 'RegisterConcrete\(&MsgRemoveReceiver{}, "lorenzo/btcstaking/MsgRemoveReceiver", nil\)' rg --type go 'RegisterConcrete\(&MsgAddReceiver{}, "lorenzo/btcstaking/MsgAddReceiver", nil\)'Length of output: 600
Script:
#!/bin/bash # Description: Verify the correctness of message identifiers for MsgRemoveReceiver and MsgAddReceiver. # Test: Check for swapped identifiers. Expect: Correct registration paths. rg --type go 'MsgRemoveReceiver.*lorenzo/btcstaking/MsgRemoveReceiver' rg --type go 'MsgAddReceiver.*lorenzo/btcstaking/MsgAddReceiver'Length of output: 367
Summary by CodeRabbit
btcstakingmodule.