Extract send fees into a page and add scenarios

Picking up work that Steyn did around various fee scenarios, and tried to marry it with what we have in the guide already. The "Send" page had a lot of fee-related info, but adding more there would have resulted in a very long page. That's why I extracting the fee content into a dedicated page that lives underneath the "Send" page.

Closes #997

_compress_images_cache.yml

@@ -2200,3 +2200,41 @@ assets/images/guide/resources/design-files/[email protected]: d
 assets/images/guide/resources/design-files/design-source-files.jpg: design-source-files.jpg
 assets/images/guide/resources/design-files/design-source-files-mobile.jpg: design-source-files-mobile.jpg
 assets/images/guide/resources/design-files/[email protected]: [email protected]
+assets/images/guide/daily-spending-wallet/sending/send-fees/fee-options-big.png: fee-options-big.png
+assets/images/guide/daily-spending-wallet/sending/send-fees/fee-options-custom-big.png: fee-options-custom-big.png
+assets/images/guide/daily-spending-wallet/sending/send-fees/fee-options-custom-options-big.png: fee-options-custom-options-big.png
+assets/images/guide/daily-spending-wallet/sending/send-fees/fee-options-custom-options.png: fee-options-custom-options.png
+assets/images/guide/daily-spending-wallet/sending/send-fees/[email protected]: [email protected]
+assets/images/guide/daily-spending-wallet/sending/send-fees/fee-options-custom.png: fee-options-custom.png
+assets/images/guide/daily-spending-wallet/sending/send-fees/[email protected]: [email protected]
+assets/images/guide/daily-spending-wallet/sending/send-fees/fee-options-high-big.png: fee-options-high-big.png
+assets/images/guide/daily-spending-wallet/sending/send-fees/fee-options-high.png: fee-options-high.png
+assets/images/guide/daily-spending-wallet/sending/send-fees/[email protected]: [email protected]
+assets/images/guide/daily-spending-wallet/sending/send-fees/fee-options-low-balance-big.png: fee-options-low-balance-big.png
+assets/images/guide/daily-spending-wallet/sending/send-fees/fee-options-low-balance.png: fee-options-low-balance.png
+assets/images/guide/daily-spending-wallet/sending/send-fees/[email protected]: [email protected]
+assets/images/guide/daily-spending-wallet/sending/send-fees/fee-options-receiver-pays-big.png: fee-options-receiver-pays-big.png
+assets/images/guide/daily-spending-wallet/sending/send-fees/fee-options-receiver-pays.png: fee-options-receiver-pays.png
+assets/images/guide/daily-spending-wallet/sending/send-fees/[email protected]: [email protected]
+assets/images/guide/daily-spending-wallet/sending/send-fees/fee-options.png: fee-options.png
+assets/images/guide/daily-spending-wallet/sending/send-fees/[email protected]: [email protected]
+assets/images/guide/daily-spending-wallet/sending/send-fees/fee-breakdown-big.png: fee-breakdown-big.png
+assets/images/guide/daily-spending-wallet/sending/send-fees/fee-breakdown-info-big.png: fee-breakdown-info-big.png
+assets/images/guide/daily-spending-wallet/sending/send-fees/fee-breakdown-info.png: fee-breakdown-info.png
+assets/images/guide/daily-spending-wallet/sending/send-fees/[email protected]: [email protected]
+assets/images/guide/daily-spending-wallet/sending/send-fees/fee-breakdown.png: fee-breakdown.png
+assets/images/guide/daily-spending-wallet/sending/send-fees/[email protected]: [email protected]
+assets/images/guide/daily-spending-wallet/sending/send-fees/lightning-fee-sample.png: lightning-fee-sample.png
+assets/images/guide/daily-spending-wallet/sending/send-fees/[email protected]: [email protected]
+assets/images/guide/daily-spending-wallet/sending/send-fees/lsp-fee-sample.png: lsp-fee-sample.png
+assets/images/guide/daily-spending-wallet/sending/send-fees/[email protected]: [email protected]
+assets/images/guide/daily-spending-wallet/sending/send-fees/onchain-fee-sample.png: onchain-fee-sample.png
+assets/images/guide/daily-spending-wallet/sending/send-fees/[email protected]: [email protected]
+assets/images/guide/daily-spending-wallet/sending/send-fees/fee-settings-big.png: fee-settings-big.png
+assets/images/guide/daily-spending-wallet/sending/send-fees/fee-settings.png: fee-settings.png
+assets/images/guide/daily-spending-wallet/sending/send-fees/[email protected]: [email protected]
+assets/images/guide/daily-spending-wallet/sending/send-fees/send-fees.jpg: send-fees.jpg
+assets/images/guide/daily-spending-wallet/sending/send-fees/[email protected]: [email protected]
+assets/images/guide/daily-spending-wallet/sending/send-fees/send-fees-mobile.jpg: send-fees-mobile.jpg
+assets/images/guide/daily-spending-wallet/sending/send-fees/[email protected]: [email protected]
+assets/images/guide/daily-spending-wallet/sending/send-fees/send-fees-preview.jpg: send-fees-preview.jpg

guide/daily-spending-wallet/activity.md

@@ -257,8 +257,8 @@ As mentioned at the top of the page, there is a lot of nuance in the display of
 Closely related to activity is the next page about [contacts]({{ '/guide/daily-spending-wallet/contacts' | relative_url }}).
 
 {% include next-previous.html
-   previousUrl = "/guide/daily-spending-wallet/sending/"
-   previousName = "Sending bitcoin"
+   previousUrl = "/guide/daily-spending-wallet/sending/send-fees/"
+   previousName = "Send fees"
    nextUrl = "/guide/daily-spending-wallet/contacts/"
    nextName = "Contacts"
 %}

guide/daily-spending-wallet/send-fees.md

@@ -0,0 +1,205 @@
+---
+layout: guide
+title: Send fees
+description: UX design guidelines for displaying bitcoin transaction fees and helping users make informed decisions.
+nav_order: 1
+parent: Sending bitcoin
+grand_parent: Daily spending wallet
+permalink: /guide/daily-spending-wallet/sending/send-fees/
+main_classes: -no-top-padding
+image: /assets/images/guide/daily-spending-wallet/sending/bitcoin-payments-social.jpg
+image_base: /assets/images/guide/daily-spending-wallet/sending/send-fees/
+images_breakdown:
+    - file: fee-breakdown
+      modalImage: fee-breakdown-big
+      alt: A send screen showing both lighting network and service fees.
+      caption: Provide a clear breakdown of expected fees.
+    - file: fee-breakdown-info
+      modalImage: fee-breakdown-info-big
+      alt: Send page with an overlay explaining swap fees.
+      caption: Allow users to quickly view explanations on (potentially unexpected) fees.
+    - file: fee-settings
+      modalImage: fee-settings-big
+      alt: Settings screen showing options for routing and channel management fees.
+      caption: Provide a settings page with more details on the fee structure.
+images_onchain:
+    - file: fee-options-low-balance
+      modalImage: fee-options-low-balance-big
+      alt: Fee picker with reduced options and an indicator stating that the balance is low.
+      caption: Options are limited when the wallet balance is low.
+    - file: fee-options-custom
+      modalImage: fee-options-custom-big
+      alt: Fee picker with the custom option highlighted.
+      caption: Custom settings are possible, even necessary, in some scenarios.
+    - file: fee-options-custom-options
+      modalImage: fee-options-custom-options-big
+      alt: Customization options in a fee picker modal.
+      caption: Users can customize the fee by adjusting different variables.
+---
+
+<!--
+
+Editor's notes
+
+This page covers best practices related to fees, both onchain and lightning.
+
+Header image source:
+https://www.figma.com/file/qzvCvqhSRx3Jq8aywaSjlr/Bitcoin-Design-Guide-Illustrations-CO?type=design&node-id=3330%3A24045&mode=design&t=0frkXfRjslx3KCdd-1
+
+Screens source (via the Bitcoin UI Kit):
+https://www.figma.com/file/VB3GQdAnhl8yta44DY3PSV/Bitcoin-UI-Kit?type=design&node-id=4954%3A34720&mode=design&t=4ATnFQwfMyYPBESL-1
+
+-->
+
+{% include picture.html
+    image = "/assets/images/guide/daily-spending-wallet/sending/send-fees/send-fees.jpg"
+    retina = "/assets/images/guide/daily-spending-wallet/sending/send-fees/send-[email protected]"
+    mobile = "/assets/images/guide/daily-spending-wallet/sending/send-fees/send-fees-mobile.jpg"
+    mobileRetina = "/assets/images/guide/daily-spending-wallet/sending/send-fees/send-[email protected]"
+    alt-text = "A postage stamp with a bitcoin symbol on it"
+    width = 1600
+    height = 500
+    layout = "full-width"
+%}
+
+# Send fees
+{:.no_toc}
+
+Fees are a necessity in a market-based network, both the base layer and lightning. They can vary drastically based on which layer the transaction is being made on, as well as the current network state, transaction complexity, whether any additional services were used, and more. To simplify this complexity for users, it is important to provide clear and actionable information and options.
+
+## Lightning fees
+
+Let's take a look at how fees surface in a regular send flow, and how users can quickly pull up additional details.
+
+{% include image-gallery.html pages = page.images_breakdown %}
+
+#### Routing fees
+
+<div class="center" markdown="1">
+
+{% include image.html
+   image = "/assets/images/guide/daily-spending-wallet/sending/send-fees/lightning-fee-sample.png"
+   retina = "/assets/images/guide/daily-spending-wallet/sending/send-fees/lightning-[email protected]"
+   alt-text = "How to display a lightning routing fee"
+   width = 400
+   height = 85
+   layout = "float-right-desktop"
+%}
+
+On the lightning network, payments are passed between nodes to get from the sender to the receiver. Each of those nodes may charge a base fee and a second fee based on a percentage of the amount forwarded. Fees paid can vary, but are typically in the single-digit or double-digit Satoshi range (a small fraction of on-chain fees).
+
+</div>
+
+#### Service fees
+
+<div class="center" markdown="1">
+
+{% include image.html
+   image = "/assets/images/guide/daily-spending-wallet/sending/send-fees/lsp-fee-sample.png"
+   retina = "/assets/images/guide/daily-spending-wallet/sending/send-fees/lsp-[email protected]"
+   alt-text = "How to display a lightning service fee"
+   width = 400
+   height = 85
+   layout = "float-right-desktop"
+%}
+
+Lightning wallets may require [additional services]({{ '/guide/how-it-works/lightning-services/' | relative_url }}) to solve certain usability issues. An example being a lightning service provider (LSP) opening payment channels and providing [inbound liquidity]({{ '/guide/how-it-works/liquidity/' | relative_url }}) for the user, so they can receive payments. As these services are offered by third parties, additional fees may be charged.
+
+</div>
+
+## On-chain fees
+
+<div class="center" markdown="1">
+
+{% include picture.html
+   image = "/assets/images/guide/daily-spending-wallet/sending/send-fees/onchain-fee-sample.png"
+   retina = "/assets/images/guide/daily-spending-wallet/sending/send-fees/onchain-[email protected]"
+   alt-text = "How to display an onchain transaction fee"
+   width = 400
+   height = 252
+   layout = "float-right-desktop"
+%}
+
+This fee is largely dependent on how many other transactions are currently [waiting]({{ '/guide/glossary/#mempool' | relative_url }}) to be processed on the base layer as a whole. The [average fee](https://ycharts.com/indicators/bitcoin_average_transaction_fee) in January 2021 was $0.63, and $28.60 in April 2021.
+
+A new block of transactions is confirmed roughly every 10 minutes. Blocks have size limits, which places a limit on the number of transactions they can contain. Transactions size itself varies with complexity. A complex multi-key transaction with many inputs and outputs involves more data, and therefore carries a higher fee, than a simple one that involves only one input and output. An organic fee market emerges from these dynamics, as miners try to earn as much as they can from fees, and transacting users try to optimize for time, fee rate, or other priorities.
+
+</div>
+
+<div class="center" markdown="1">
+
+{% include picture.html
+   image = "/assets/images/guide/daily-spending-wallet/sending/send-fees/fee-options.png"
+   retina = "/assets/images/guide/daily-spending-wallet/sending/send-fees/fee-[email protected]"
+   modalImage = "/assets/images/guide/daily-spending-wallet/sending/send-fees/fee-options-big.png"
+   alt-text = "Screen showing fee options for an onchain transaction"
+   caption = "A simple framework for on-chain fees is the urgency of the transaction."
+   width = 250
+   height = 541
+   layout = "float-right-desktop -background -shadow"
+%}
+
+Generally, it is best to dynamically calculate a reasonable fee range and provide a few simple options based on how urgent the transaction is for the user. Total cost and confirmation time are often the primary decision points.
+
+</div>
+
+#### High fee situations
+
+<div class="center" markdown="1">
+
+{% include image.html
+   image = "/assets/images/guide/daily-spending-wallet/sending/send-fees/fee-options-high.png"
+   retina = "/assets/images/guide/daily-spending-wallet/sending/send-fees/fee-[email protected]"
+   alt-text = "Screen showing a fee picker for an onchain transaction with high fee options marked in red"
+   width = 250
+   height = 541
+   layout = "float-right-desktop -background -shadow"
+%}
+
+Unfortunately, it is common for users to overpay on-chain fees by mistake. Wallets should have mechanisms in place to avoid this from happening.
+
+If a user's transaction amount is low compared to the fee they would pay to broadcast, warn them. There are no standards regarding the threshold percentage to trigger such an alert. A good benchmark is to warn the user if their fee is 50% or more than the value of the transaction itself. You might choose a different threshold for your app. Procedures like this should be enough to ensure users do not overpay on-chain fees unintentionally.
+
+</div>
+
+#### Including the fee in the amount
+
+<div class="center" markdown="1">
+
+{% include picture.html
+   image = "/assets/images/guide/daily-spending-wallet/sending/send-fees/fee-options-receiver-pays.png"
+   retina = "/assets/images/guide/daily-spending-wallet/sending/send-fees/fee-[email protected]"
+   modalImage = "/assets/images/guide/daily-spending-wallet/sending/send-fees/fee-options-receiver-pays-big.png"
+   alt-text = ""
+   caption = "Users can choose to put the fee burden on the receiver."
+   width = 250
+   height = 541
+   layout = "float-right-desktop -background -shadow"
+%}
+
+The most common scenario is that sender and receiver have an understanding of how much to exchange, and the sender is also responsible for paying the fee. However, there are situations where this is not wanted or possible:
+
+1. Sender and receiver agree that the receiver will cover the fee
+2. The sender balance is enough to cover the amount to pay, but not the fee
+3. The sender wants to clear out the wallet, possibly to migrate
+
+To accomodate these, the interface also needs to provide manual customization options, although they can be placed into secondary location.
+
+</div>
+
+#### Other scenarios
+
+The visuals below illustrate additional scenarios and states, for when the users balance is so low that they may not be able to pay for the fee, and for customizing the fee in detail.
+
+{% include image-gallery.html pages = page.images_onchain %}
+
+---
+
+Now that we've tackled sending and receiving, let's look at how we can summarize this [activity]({{ '/guide/daily-spending-wallet/activity/' | relative_url }}) and make it useful.
+
+{% include next-previous.html
+   previousUrl = "/guide/daily-spending-wallet/sending/"
+   previousName = "Sending bitcoin"
+   nextUrl = "/guide/daily-spending-wallet/activity/"
+   nextName = "Activity"
+%}

guide/daily-spending-wallet/sending.md

@@ -2,6 +2,7 @@
 layout: guide
 title: Sending bitcoin
 description: Best practices and design guidelines for designing user experiences for sending bitcoin in daily spending wallet application.
+has_children: true
 nav_order: 4
 parent: Daily spending wallet
 permalink: /guide/daily-spending-wallet/sending/
@@ -112,7 +113,7 @@ imagesReview:
     - file: confirm-high-fees
       modalImage: confirm-high-fees-big
       alt: Confirmation screen with note about high fees
-      caption: Highlight information the user should consciously approve, like high fees.
+      caption: Highlight information the user should be aware of, like high fees (See <a href="/guide/daily-spending-wallet/sending/send-fees/">send fees</a>)
     - file: enter-pin-before-payment
       modalImage: enter-pin-before-payment-big
       alt: Enter PIN screen
@@ -226,51 +227,7 @@ A [transaction history]({{ '/guide/daily-spending-wallet/activity/' | relative_u
 
 ## Fees
 
-Payment fees can drastically differ based on a few attributes:
-
-<div class="center" markdown="1">
-
-{% include image.html
-   image = "/assets/images/guide/daily-spending-wallet/sending/fee-options.png"
-   retina = "/assets/images/guide/daily-spending-wallet/sending/fee-[email protected]"
-   alt-text = "Examples of on-chain, lightning and lightning routing fees"
-   width = 400
-   height = 417
-   layout = "float-right-desktop"
-%}
-
-**Lightning routing fees**
-
-On the lightning network, payments are passed between nodes to get from the sender to the receiver. Each of those nodes may charge a base fee and a second fee based on a percentage of the amount forwarded. Fees paid can vary, but are typically in the single-digit or double-digit Satoshi range (a small fraction of on-chain fees).
-
-**Lightning service fees**
-
-Lightning wallets may require [additional services]({{ '/guide/how-it-works/lightning-services/' | relative_url }}) to solve certain usability issues. An example being a lightning service provider (LSP) opening payment channels and providing [inbound liquidity]({{ '/guide/how-it-works/liquidity/' | relative_url }}) for the user, so they can receive payments. As these services are offered by third parties, additional fees may be charged.
-
-</div>
-
-<div class="center" markdown="1">
-
-#### On-chain fees
-
-{% include picture.html
-   image = "/assets/images/guide/daily-spending-wallet/sending/confirm-fees.png"
-   retina = "/assets/images/guide/daily-spending-wallet/sending/confirm-[email protected]"
-   modalImage = "/assets/images/guide/daily-spending-wallet/sending/confirm-fees-big.png"
-   alt-text = "Screen showing fee options for a transaction"
-   caption = "On-chain fees can vary drastically and should be easy to edit."
-   width = 250
-   height = 541
-   layout = "float-right-desktop -background -shadow"
-%}
-
-This fee is dependent on how many other transactions are currently [waiting]({{ '/guide/glossary/#mempool' | relative_url }}) to be processed on the base layer as a whole. The [average fee](https://ycharts.com/indicators/bitcoin_average_transaction_fee) in January 2021 was $0.63, and $28.60 in April 2021.
-
-Unfortunately, it is common for users to overpay on-chain fees by mistake. Wallets should have mechanisms in place to avoid this happening.
-
-If a user's transaction amount is low compared to the fee they would pay to broadcast, warn them. There are no standards regarding the threshold percentage to trigger such an alert. A good benchmark is to warn the user if their fee is 50% or more than the value of the transaction itself. You might choose a different threshold for your app. Procedures like this should be enough to ensure users do not overpay on-chain fees unintentionally.
-
-</div>
+Fees are a sensitive topic for users and should always be presented transparently with appropriate information and options for users to choose what works for them. The network itself charges fees for payment processing, and a service provider might also charge fees for services they provide in addition (like providing lightning liquidity). For more details, see the [send fees page]({{ '/guide/daily-spending-wallet/sending/send-fees/' | relative_url }}).
 
 ## Review & approval
 
@@ -368,11 +325,11 @@ On-chain wallets may offer experienced users the option to choose which of their
 
 ---
 
-Now that we've tackled sending and receiving, let's look at how we can summarize this [activity]({{ '/guide/daily-spending-wallet/activity/' | relative_url }}) and make it useful.
+Let's look a closer look at [send feed]({{ '/guide/daily-spending-wallet/sending/send-fees/' | relative_url }}).
 
 {% include next-previous.html
    previousUrl = "/guide/daily-spending-wallet/requesting/receiving/"
    previousName = "Receiving bitcoin"
-   nextUrl = "/guide/daily-spending-wallet/activity/"
-   nextName = "Activity"
+   nextUrl = "/guide/daily-spending-wallet/sending/send-fees"
+   nextName = "Send fees"
 %}