F1000 Bugfixes

[CaptainSifff]

• Fix icon size
• Fix affiliation @BeastyBlacksmith
• Fix icons are broken links in the text

Feel free to add here, so that we can fix that when the reviews are in!

[CaptainSifff]

first report: https://f1000research.com/articles/13-1429/v1#referee-response-345505

[BeastyBlacksmith]

What a lovely report. Lots of good points in there

[MakisH]

Also is it meant to be aspirational (e.g., all RSEs should have these) or does it represent the current state of RSEs (e.g., most RSEs already have these competencies)?

I think this is a confusion we had at different phases and indeed we are probably not consistent (let's check the tables again, for example). I think that we have converged to "RSEs should have these", but we arrive on these points partially based on the what RSEs already have.

Section 5.3 (Project team structures) - there is a gap here: "The single RSE on a team of not-RSEs who does not have a central RSE team connection." These do exist (sadly).

Probably a nice forward-reference to the institutions paper(s)?

I really like the following suggestions for more text:

• funding methods (but how do we make it fit the teaching aspects?)
• RSEs being integrated into existing teams and having to fight that team's culture

How do we proceed with the editing/revision? Continue editing normally here, or is that complicated to port to the system again?

Do we need patches, instead?

Where do we write the reply to the reviewers?

[mhagdorn]

with regards to the icons. I wonder if we should drop them for the F1000 publication and keep them for the arxiv version. a suitable latex conditional could do the trick. This might also help with the workflow for addressing the issues/suggestions raised by the reviewers:

• modify the document here as we have done before
• convert it to docx at the end which maybe simpler

That way we get to stick our tried and tested workflow and also update the arxiv version of the paper

[CaptainSifff]

For the time being, I cannot upload a RTF, or DOC Version.... Their download is broken...

[CaptainSifff]

So we now have a file from F1000. I can open it with the MS365 word version, but not with loffice.
So remember for the future changes:

• change markdown file
• modify docx file
• put a note into response_to referee.md

[BeastyBlacksmith]

I would prefer working with a rtf file to be honest

[CaptainSifff]

their rtf download is broken, sorry.