Cannot create renamed copies of members of this using export

[neko-kai]

Minimized code

abstract class WordSpec {
  export this.{extension_in => extension_should}
  
  extension(s: String) def in(f: => Any): Unit = {
    println(s)
    f
  }
}

object test extends WordSpec {  
  "X" should {
    "add numbers" in {
     assert(1 + 1 == 2)
    }
  }
}

Output

no eligible member extension_in at this
this.extension_in cannot be exported because it is already a member of class AnyWordSpec
  export this.{extension_in => extension_should}

Expectation

Seems like the check for duplicates is over-eager and happens before renames are taken into account, making it illegal to rename symbols in this, but legal otherwise. Workaround is to create a proxy object and re-export from it:

abstract class WordSpec {
  export inner.{extension_in => extension_should}
  export inner.extension_in
  
  object inner {
    extension(s: String) def in(f: => Any): Unit = {
      println(s)
      f
    }
  }
}

[odersky]

The behavior corresponds to what the spec says:

A member is eligible if all of the following holds:

• its owner is not a base class of the class(*) containing the export clause, ...

If we want to change this we'd need a feature request, and a discussion in depth. I personally think that a change would not be simple at all. There would be many things to specify, what constutes a clash and what doesn't.

[som-snytt]

Existing feature request at lampepfl/dotty-feature-requests#148