You signed in with another tab or window. Reload to refresh your session.You signed out in another tab or window. Reload to refresh your session.You switched accounts on another tab or window. Reload to refresh your session.Dismiss alert
the RV32/64G instruction set listing chapter is a really handy summary for those of us who have to work on assemblers/disassemblers/emulators. recent versions of the spec are a great improvement in terms of actually including the funct3 values [etc] in binary when introducing instructions (100 is more helpful than XOR as a funct3 "value", obviously). but the instruction set listing chapter is a great quick reference guide, and i don't understand why it's only G, not all the extensions described in the rest of the doc?
(obviously i'm at risk of having this resolved as "yeah, let's remove the whole chapter!" rather than "yeah, let's make that chapter complete!", but i would have to grudgingly admit that that's at least consistent :-) )
The text was updated successfully, but these errors were encountered:
i'd also reference "26.8. RVC Instruction Set Listings" and ask why that's in a chapter of its own (and thus, if nothing else, harder to find) rather than combined with all the "G" instruction set listings? and why "C" gets this special treatment, but Zc* doesn't...
recent versions of the spec are a great improvement in terms of actually including the funct3 values [etc] in binary when introducing instructions (100 is more helpful than XOR as a funct3 "value", obviously).
actually, i picked a bad example there :-)
although newer instructions (like for example "27.12.7 c.sext.b") are in this better format, old instructions haven't been retconned into the newer better format. specifically for xor, "2.4.2. Integer Register-Register Operations" currently still has "AND/OR/XOR" as the funct3 "value", forcing the reader to go and look at the "RV32/64G instruction set listing" chapter.
the RV32/64G instruction set listing chapter is a really handy summary for those of us who have to work on assemblers/disassemblers/emulators. recent versions of the spec are a great improvement in terms of actually including the funct3 values [etc] in binary when introducing instructions (100 is more helpful than XOR as a funct3 "value", obviously). but the instruction set listing chapter is a great quick reference guide, and i don't understand why it's only G, not all the extensions described in the rest of the doc?
(obviously i'm at risk of having this resolved as "yeah, let's remove the whole chapter!" rather than "yeah, let's make that chapter complete!", but i would have to grudgingly admit that that's at least consistent :-) )
The text was updated successfully, but these errors were encountered: