diff --git a/src/pokedex_plus_hgss.c b/src/pokedex_plus_hgss.c
index 74b57fa3a50b..8782044769c6 100644
--- a/src/pokedex_plus_hgss.c
+++ b/src/pokedex_plus_hgss.c
@@ -2560,11 +2560,11 @@ static void CreatePokedexList(u8 dexMode, u8 order)
         }
         break;
     case ORDER_ALPHABETICAL:
-        for (i = 0; i < NUM_SPECIES - 1; i++)
+        for (i = 0; i < NATIONAL_DEX_COUNT; i++)
         {
             temp_dexNum = gPokedexOrder_Alphabetical[i];
 
-            if (NationalToHoennOrder(temp_dexNum) <= temp_dexCount && GetSetPokedexFlag(temp_dexNum, FLAG_GET_SEEN))
+            if ((!temp_isHoennDex || NationalToHoennOrder(temp_dexNum) != 0) && GetSetPokedexFlag(temp_dexNum, FLAG_GET_SEEN))
             {
                 sPokedexView->pokedexList[sPokedexView->pokemonListCount].dexNum = temp_dexNum;
                 sPokedexView->pokedexList[sPokedexView->pokemonListCount].seen = TRUE;
@@ -2578,7 +2578,7 @@ static void CreatePokedexList(u8 dexMode, u8 order)
         {
             temp_dexNum = gPokedexOrder_Weight[i];
 
-            if (NationalToHoennOrder(temp_dexNum) <= temp_dexCount && GetSetPokedexFlag(temp_dexNum, FLAG_GET_CAUGHT))
+            if ((!temp_isHoennDex || NationalToHoennOrder(temp_dexNum) != 0) && GetSetPokedexFlag(temp_dexNum, FLAG_GET_CAUGHT))
             {
                 sPokedexView->pokedexList[sPokedexView->pokemonListCount].dexNum = temp_dexNum;
                 sPokedexView->pokedexList[sPokedexView->pokemonListCount].seen = TRUE;
@@ -2592,7 +2592,7 @@ static void CreatePokedexList(u8 dexMode, u8 order)
         {
             temp_dexNum = gPokedexOrder_Weight[i];
 
-            if (NationalToHoennOrder(temp_dexNum) <= temp_dexCount && GetSetPokedexFlag(temp_dexNum, FLAG_GET_CAUGHT))
+            if ((!temp_isHoennDex || NationalToHoennOrder(temp_dexNum) != 0) && GetSetPokedexFlag(temp_dexNum, FLAG_GET_CAUGHT))
             {
                 sPokedexView->pokedexList[sPokedexView->pokemonListCount].dexNum = temp_dexNum;
                 sPokedexView->pokedexList[sPokedexView->pokemonListCount].seen = TRUE;
@@ -2606,7 +2606,7 @@ static void CreatePokedexList(u8 dexMode, u8 order)
         {
             temp_dexNum = gPokedexOrder_Height[i];
 
-            if (NationalToHoennOrder(temp_dexNum) <= temp_dexCount && GetSetPokedexFlag(temp_dexNum, FLAG_GET_CAUGHT))
+            if ((!temp_isHoennDex || NationalToHoennOrder(temp_dexNum) != 0) && GetSetPokedexFlag(temp_dexNum, FLAG_GET_CAUGHT))
             {
                 sPokedexView->pokedexList[sPokedexView->pokemonListCount].dexNum = temp_dexNum;
                 sPokedexView->pokedexList[sPokedexView->pokemonListCount].seen = TRUE;
@@ -2620,7 +2620,7 @@ static void CreatePokedexList(u8 dexMode, u8 order)
         {
             temp_dexNum = gPokedexOrder_Height[i];
 
-            if (NationalToHoennOrder(temp_dexNum) <= temp_dexCount && GetSetPokedexFlag(temp_dexNum, FLAG_GET_CAUGHT))
+            if ((!temp_isHoennDex || NationalToHoennOrder(temp_dexNum) != 0) && GetSetPokedexFlag(temp_dexNum, FLAG_GET_CAUGHT))
             {
                 sPokedexView->pokedexList[sPokedexView->pokemonListCount].dexNum = temp_dexNum;
                 sPokedexView->pokedexList[sPokedexView->pokemonListCount].seen = TRUE;