You signed in with another tab or window. Reload to refresh your session.You signed out in another tab or window. Reload to refresh your session.You switched accounts on another tab or window. Reload to refresh your session.Dismiss alert
Not sure if related to #66. (Don't know enough of the parser rules. Clearly. 😅 Or concrete implementations.)
My main "gripe" with implied names is that I go through "all this hassle" (not really, but you know what I mean) to actually exclude p-name from my clearly microformatted reply (and repost, etc.) contexts (using h-cite), only to later find out parsers just assume the page I'm referring to is titled ... whatever the entire reply context happens to say? (Like: No, this is a note. I'm referring to a note. There is no title. 😬)
Now I could come up with some workarounds (use an entirely different HTML structure), but ... I'd rather keep my markup somewhat consistent. (Total side note: I've also seen "examples in the wild" with, e.g., Replying to <span class="p-name">a note</a> by <span class="p-author ... and so on, which I'd argue is "even worse." That note is almost certainly not titled "a note.")
I totally understand the need to "fall back" to "metaformats" (be it Open Graph tags or a title element) when referring to remote pages or articles that clearly do have a title but don't support mf2. But this is not such a case (I would say).
Absolutely open for other ideas, too (like, how to improve my markup)!
The text was updated successfully, but these errors were encountered:
As brought up in microformats/php-mf2#267.
Not sure if related to #66. (Don't know enough of the parser rules. Clearly. 😅 Or concrete implementations.)
My main "gripe" with implied names is that I go through "all this hassle" (not really, but you know what I mean) to actually exclude
p-name
from my clearly microformatted reply (and repost, etc.) contexts (usingh-cite
), only to later find out parsers just assume the page I'm referring to is titled ... whatever the entire reply context happens to say? (Like: No, this is a note. I'm referring to a note. There is no title. 😬)Now I could come up with some workarounds (use an entirely different HTML structure), but ... I'd rather keep my markup somewhat consistent. (Total side note: I've also seen "examples in the wild" with, e.g.,
Replying to <span class="p-name">a note</a> by <span class="p-author ...
and so on, which I'd argue is "even worse." That note is almost certainly not titled "a note.")I totally understand the need to "fall back" to "metaformats" (be it Open Graph tags or a
title
element) when referring to remote pages or articles that clearly do have a title but don't support mf2. But this is not such a case (I would say).Absolutely open for other ideas, too (like, how to improve my markup)!
The text was updated successfully, but these errors were encountered: