diff --git a/frontend/src/pages/destructionlist/review/DestructionListReview.stories.tsx b/frontend/src/pages/destructionlist/review/DestructionListReview.stories.tsx
index 2c6923a9..1eda330e 100644
--- a/frontend/src/pages/destructionlist/review/DestructionListReview.stories.tsx
+++ b/frontend/src/pages/destructionlist/review/DestructionListReview.stories.tsx
@@ -12,7 +12,7 @@ import {
   destructionListAssigneesFactory,
   destructionListFactory,
 } from "../../../fixtures/destructionList";
-import { paginatedDestructionListItemsFailedFactory } from "../../../fixtures/destructionListItem";
+import { paginatedDestructionListItemsFactory } from "../../../fixtures/destructionListItem";
 import { reviewFactory } from "../../../fixtures/review";
 import {
   beoordelaarFactory,
@@ -20,15 +20,7 @@ import {
   userFactory,
   usersFactory,
 } from "../../../fixtures/user";
-import {
-  getFilteredZaakSelection,
-  getZaakSelectionItems,
-} from "../../../lib/zaakSelection";
-import { Zaak } from "../../../types";
-import {
-  DestructionListReviewPage,
-  getDestructionListReviewKey,
-} from "./DestructionListReview";
+import { DestructionListReviewPage } from "./DestructionListReview";
 import { destructionListReviewAction } from "./DestructionListReview.action";
 import { DestructionListReviewContext } from "./DestructionListReview.loader";
 
@@ -175,47 +167,14 @@ const FIXTURE: DestructionListReviewContext = {
   logItems: [],
   review: reviewFactory(),
   reviewers: usersFactory(),
-  paginatedZaken: paginatedDestructionListItemsFailedFactory(),
+  paginatedZaken: paginatedDestructionListItemsFactory(),
 };
 
 export const ReviewerCanApproveZaak: Story = {
   parameters: {
     reactRouterDecorator: {
       route: {
-        loader: async () => {
-          const storageKey = getDestructionListReviewKey(
-            FIXTURE.uuid,
-            FIXTURE.destructionList.status,
-          );
-          const zakenResults = FIXTURE.paginatedZaken.results
-            .map((zaak) => zaak.zaak)
-            .filter((zaak) => zaak !== null) as Zaak[];
-          const zakenOnPage = zakenResults.map((z) => z.url as string);
-
-          const approvedZaakUrlsOnPagePromise = await Promise.all(
-            zakenOnPage.map(async (url) => {
-              const selection = await getZaakSelectionItems<{
-                approved: boolean;
-              }>(storageKey, [url]);
-              const item = selection[url];
-              return { url, approved: item?.detail?.approved };
-            }),
-          );
-
-          const approvedZaakUrlsOnPage = approvedZaakUrlsOnPagePromise
-            .filter((result) => result.approved)
-            .map((result) => result.url);
-
-          const excludedZaakSelection = await getFilteredZaakSelection<{
-            approved: false;
-          }>(storageKey, { approved: false });
-
-          return {
-            ...FIXTURE,
-            approvedZaakUrlsOnPage,
-            excludedZaakSelection,
-          };
-        },
+        loader: async () => FIXTURE,
         action: destructionListReviewAction,
       },
     },
@@ -227,8 +186,10 @@ export const ReviewerCanApproveZaak: Story = {
     });
     const approve = approves[0];
     await userEvent.click(approve);
-    const checkbox = await canvas.findByRole("checkbox", { checked: true });
-    await expect(checkbox).toBeInTheDocument();
+    // Find all checkboxes
+    const checkboxes = await canvas.findAllByRole("checkbox");
+    const checkbox = checkboxes[0];
+    await expect(checkbox).toBeChecked();
   },
 };