ios_system should wait for all commands in line

[yury]

Example:

echo 'nice' | ssh host

Currently ios_system exits after first command (echo nice) and start second command (ssh host).
But we already show blink> prompt :)

[holzschu]

Indeed. I see where the problem comes from, but the solution is not obvious. Commands should wait for all commands they have started (either with pipe or fork/exec/system), but not for the others. Making sure the command is not blocked by a command in another terminal is the tricky bit.

I'm going to think about it.

[yury]

I think this is related issue blinksh/blink#637

[yury]

May by whole ios_system should be as meta program...

[holzschu]

The two issues were not related, but I have committed a fix for blinksh/blink#637

I'm not sure what you mean by meta program; would you have a pointer to some documentation?

[holzschu]

Fix committed for this issue (f10015f).
It was a bug I introduced with a recent change (introduction of pthread_detach at line 1390 of ios_system.m). We've now reverted to the previous behaviour:

• wait for the first command in the pipe to terminate (with pthread_join)
• then wait for the last command in the pipe to terminate (with pthread_join too)
  Which works for these commands, and for multiple pipes too.

The mistake I made was that once a thread has been detached, it cannot be joined again. Now, we don't detach the last command in the pipe, so we can join it later.

[yury]

Good catch. Ignore my meta program thing :)

Will try it tomorrow

Thank you

[yury]

Works for me. Thank you!

[yury]

echo nice | ssh office cat somehow try to run office cat as command.
ssh is using getopts to parse args, how can I use getopts from ios_system?

If I add sleep(1); before parsing args it works as expected :)

[holzschu]

Hmmm.... that's odd.

[yury]

For a test, I copied getopts from ios_system and make all vars with thread_ prefix. And it works.