zsh support

[kubukoz]

Especially when used with direnv - it'd be nice to keep a similar UX to what plain Nix with flakes does.

devenv:

direnv with flakes:

[domenkozar]

Here's where we set $PS1: https://github.com/cachix/devenv/blob/main/src/modules/top-level.nix#L81

How should it be adapted for zsh?

[kubukoz]

hmm, I think I got confused here. I thought since the prompt says bash, we're actually in bash - but this would suggest otherwise:

[shyim]

I guess with devenv your actual shell is bash and not your configured one. I guess the SHELL env gets not overwritten and is from the parent shell

[koiuo]

@domenkozar , I think the author wanted devenv to launch zsh rather than bash. It's not about PS1.

We can't really compare to direnv, it's a different beast, a more fair would be a comparison to nix-shell. It too launches bash no matter what.

There's a 7-year old issue about supporting shells other than bash in nix-shell. It's still open 🙈
NixOS/nix#545

@kubukoz , one way to check your shell from within is

echo $0

[manveru]

Yeah, this is the main thing keeping me from using direnv+devenv over direnv+mkShell... forcing people into using bash isn't an option for me.

[domenkozar]

@manveru I'd really like to fix this but I'm not sure how to reproduce the issue.

[manveru]

I have this in .envrc:

watch_file devenv.nix
watch_file devenv.yaml
watch_file devenv.lock
if [[ ! "$DIRENV_ACTIVE" =~ (^|:)"$PWD"(:|$) ]]; then
  devenv shell
fi

and it starts a new bash instead of exporting the environment to zsh.

[domenkozar]

And this otherwise works with nix develop? If I understand correctly, nix always launches bash.

[manveru]

Yeah, I don't use nix develop when direnv+use flake is possible if i want to run more than one or two commands. I'd rather not spend time customizing bash to become approximately as usable as my zsh setup.
TBH I'm not sure there's a way to achieve this, and for the time being I'm adopting a combination of flake-parts+mkShell+direnv+use flake, which works nicely but obviously requires quite a bit more boilerplate and lacks the immediate support for all those language environments out of the box.

[domenkozar]

https://ianthehenry.com/posts/how-to-learn-nix/nix-zshell/ shows just how painful it is to support zsh. I'm going to work on #240 to fix this.

[jasonprado]

any-nix-shell manages to make nix-shell -p cowsay launch a zsh shell for me with only ~2 lines of config in my home-manager setup. It'd be great if launching devenv shell did the same! I opened an issue there to discuss: haslersn/any-nix-shell#33

[rolfschr]

The following is sufficient for me:

  enterShell = ''
    exec fish
  '';

I also have this for my prompt (fish) specifically for nix-shell but it worked also for devenv shell:

  if test -n "$IN_NIX_SHELL"
    set_color cyan; printf "[nix-shell] "; set_color normal
  end

[agj]

Hello! Ran into this problem today. When using plain Nix flakes, I use nix develop -c $SHELL to start it in my own choice of shell. It's easy to put that command in a task runner and make it easy for the whole team. But there's no similar option with devenv shell that I could find. Any chance that this flag could be added?

[Shyrogan]

The following is sufficient for me:

enterShell = ''
exec fish
'';

I also have this for my prompt (fish) specifically for nix-shell but it worked also for devenv shell:

if test -n "$IN_NIX_SHELL"
set_color cyan; printf "[nix-shell] "; set_color normal
end

While this works, it kinda gets annoying when working with services, running devenv up will open a new fish shell instead of opening the terminal UI for services.