cannot stow ".gitignore"

[fenugrec]

Heh, I just figured it out while writing this (is there a "rubberduck" label ?). So it's not really a bug report anymore, but I'd like to discuss it anyway - feel free to close at any time.

I was trying to stow ~/.gitconfig and ~/.gitignore . The first worked, but I just could not make it work with .gitignore !

Turning on -vvvvv revealed the explanation :

Using built-in ignore list
    Ignore list regexp for paths:    /(?^:(^|/)(^/README.*|^/LICENSE.*|^/\.stow\-local\-ignore$|^/COPYING)(/|$))/
    Ignore list regexp for segments: /(?^:^(\.hg|CVS|.+,v|\.gitignore|\.svn|#.*#|\.cvsignore|\.#.+|_darcs|.+~|\.git|RCS)$)/

I understand the reason for ignoring those in the root of the "stow directory", but I'm not sure when they would be a problem coming from within a package ?
Unless those regexp are mainly so that --adopt doesn't pick up all that trash ?

I know how to work around this ; just add --dotfiles in .stowrc , and rename files to dot-gitconfig and dot-gitignore, so as I said this isn't really an issue.

[aspiers]

The point is that typically when stowing from a package which is a git repo, the .gitignore at the top of that repo is intended only for use within the git repo, and should not be stowed into ~ or /usr/local or wherever the stow target directory is. The only exception is when you want to use Stow to manage ~/.gitignore (say) as a symlink pointing to a file version-controlled with git. In that case, you can set up a .stow-local-ignore just for that git repo which overrides Stow's default ignore list and allows the .gitignore to be stowed. In fact I do exactly that myself: https://github.com/aspiers/git-config/blob/master/.stow-local-ignore

Hope that makes sense, and sorry for the slow reply! Closing for now, but happy to reopen if anything is unclear.

[fenugrec]

and sorry for the slow reply!

Haha no worries I've seen / done worse.

Thanks for the alternate solution, I wasn't aware of .stow-local-ignore.
I still think it's an interesting edge case / typical scenario; next time someone asks it may need to be added to the FAQ !

[aspiers]

@fenugrec commented on April 5, 2021 1:09 AM:

and sorry for the slow reply!

Haha no worries I've seen / done worse.

😆 Thanks for your patience!

Thanks for the alternate solution, I wasn't aware of .stow-local-ignore.
I still think it's an interesting edge case / typical scenario; next time someone asks it may need to be added to the FAQ !

Yep, fair point. We don't actually have a FAQ yet, but there is a section on Ignore Lists in the manual. If you have any ideas for how to improve that, I'd be happy to hear them!

[whompyjaw]

Hmm.. I must not be as savvy as OP, but can't seem to understand the issue. I wonder if I am doing something wrong?

I put my .gitconfig and .gitignore in ~/.dotfiles/git which is vc'd using a normal git repo that makes ~/ as my work-tree (have an alias, similar to the "bare" concept, just not a bare repo basically). This seems to work fine. I think because I set my work-tree to $HOME. So it pulls the gitignore from home. Not my dotfiles. Does that make sense?

[afrid18]

I don't have .gitignore file in the .stow-global-ignore and yet I am unable to stow it.

Here is my verbose output:

  dotfiles/git/.stow-local-ignore didn't exist
  /Users/imamkhaja/.stow-global-ignore didn't exist
  Using built-in ignore list
    Ignore list regexp for paths:    /(?^:(^|/)(^/\.stow\-local\-ignore$|^/COPYING|^/LICENSE.*|^/README.*)(/|$))/
    Ignore list regexp for segments: /(?^:^(\.git|.+~|_darcs|.+,v|RCS|\.gitignore|#.*#|CVS|\.cvsignore|\.svn|\.#.+|\.hg)$)/
  Ignoring path segment .gitignore

It seems that segments ignore list is the reason, that .gitignore isn't stowing, if I am not worng.

[nineboxes]

Hello there. I also can't stow the .gitignore by eliminating it from the .stow-local-ignore file on the macOS.
@aspiers sorry for bothering you, could you please take a look?

[fenugrec]

quoting the first post :

just add --dotfiles in .stowrc , and rename files to dot-gitconfig and dot-gitignore, so as I said this isn't really an issue.

that's how I solved it

[FWDekker]

@afrid18 @nineboxes Just create an empty .stow-local-ignore in ~/.dotfiles/git. The point is not to override your global ignore file, but to override Stow's internal default ignore file.

[1player]

This is still an issue with the --dotfiles option. I understand the rationale of ignoring .gitignore, but dot-gitignore is also skipped which is a bug.

[aspiers]

@1player Did you try this?

[1player]

I did and fixes it, but it seems to me stow should rightly ignore .gitignore by default, but not dot-gitignore. In other words, checking if a file should be skipped should happen _before_ replacing the dot- string in the filename with a literal dot, which how I expected it to behave.

…

On Sun, 8 Sep 2024, at 11:02, Adam Spiers wrote: @1player <https://github.com/1player> Did you try this <#75 (comment)>? — Reply to this email directly, view it on GitHub <#75 (comment)>, or unsubscribe <https://github.com/notifications/unsubscribe-auth/AAFIPSDDZT7EZUQD2O7HEHDZVQOCTAVCNFSM6AAAAABN2ZM6JKVHI2DSMVQWIX3LMV43OSLTON2WKQ3PNVWWK3TUHMZDGMZWGYZDIMJTGQ>. You are receiving this because you were mentioned.Message ID: ***@***.***>

[aspiers]

I think you are right, because something called dot-gitignore is obviously named that way because it was intended to be stowed. Please could you file a separate issue for that? I have checked the code and it looks like it's probably easy to fix.

[aspiers]

Fix submitted as #116, please can you test?