NOUS A5T Buttons do not work on Tasmota 14.2.0

[DanielH1987]

I've got two of the A5T and with Tasmota 14.1.0 everything works fine.
If I update to 14.2.0 everything works except the buttons for turning on/off the outlets.
The Rules are correct and enabled (buttons work as voltage dividers for the analog input).
I returned to 14.1.0 and it works again - on both Powerstrips.
So I suspect it's a problem with the version. But I'm very unsure if I should open an Issue.

[barbudor]

Strange
I have a Gosund P1 which is exactly the same hardware as the Nous A5T and I'm running Tasmota 14.2.0.2 without any issues. Can you try the latest development version instead of the release ?

[barbudor]

Could you please report

• your current rules
• the different values of the analog input when buttons are not pressed and for each button pressed

[sfromis]

There was some recent enhancements around analog handling, hence the output from commands AdcParam and AdcGpiio could also be good to check.

[DanielH1987]

On 14.1:
{"Rule1":{"State":"ON","Once":"OFF","StopOnError":"OFF","Length":34,"Free":477,"Rules":"ON Button1#State DO Power4 2 ENDON"}}
{"Rule2":{"State":"ON","Once":"ON","StopOnError":"OFF","Length":150,"Free":361,"Rules":"ON Analog#A0div10<30 DO Power3 2 BREAK ON Analog#A0div10<60 DO Power2 2 BREAK ON Analog#A0div10<80 DO Power1 2 ENDON BACKLOG RULE1 1; RULE2 1; RULE2 5"}}
{"Rule3":{"State":"ON","Once":"OFF","StopOnError":"OFF","Length":203,"Free":308,"Rules":"ON Energy#Power>%var1% DO Backlog var1 %value%; TelePeriod 3600; var2 %value%; add1 10; sub2 10 ENDON ON Energy#Power<%var2% DO Backlog var2 %value%; TelePeriod 3600; var1 %value%; add1 10; sub2 10 ENDON"}}

{"AdcParam1":[1,0,0,0.0005,0]}
AdcGpio - command unknown

Analog1 Values - Button 1: 741; Button 2: 465; Button 3: 217

On 14.2:
Identical to 14.1

{"AdcParam1":[17,0,0,5,0]}
{"AdcGpio":[0,0,5,0]}

Analog1 Values - Button 1: 740; Button 2: 465; Button 3: 215
(But I guess those slight deviations don't matter.)

[DanielH1987]

Got it:
Has to be:
{"AdcGpio":[0,1024,5,0]}

[HofeBY]

@DanielH1987
can you show us the Infosite of Tasmota ?

[sfromis]

While the AdcParam output did indeed show the problem, I suspect that it may have been broken by downgrading to a previous version, which is not an operation supported by Tasmota.

[DanielH1987]

On those two devices I only ever upgraded versions. Always the release, with the exception of the dev version earlier because it was suggested.

[DanielH1987]

Program Version 14.2.0 (release-tasmota)
Build Date & Time 2024-08-14T12:36:35
Core/SDK Version 2_7_7/2.2.2-dev(38a443e)
Uptime 0T03:20:16
Flash Write Count 3931 at 0xF4000
Boot Count 104
Restart Reason Software/System restart
Friendly Name 1
Friendly Name 2
Friendly Name 3
Friendly Name 4
AP2 Information SSId
RSSI 68%, -66 dBm
Mode 11n
Channel 1
BSSId
Hostname
MAC Address
IP Address (WiFi)
Gateway
Subnet Mask 255.255.255.0
DNS Server1
DNS Server2 0.0.0.0
HTTP API Disabled
MQTT Host
MQTT Port 1883
MQTT User
MQTT Client
MQTT Topic
MQTT Group Topic 1 cmnd/tasmotas/
MQTT Full Topic cmnd/
MQTT Fallback Topic cmnd/
MQTT No Retain Disabled
Emulation None
ESP Chip Id 14431124 (ESP8285N08)
Flash Chip Id 0x144051 (DOUT)
Flash Size 1024 KB
Program Flash Size 1024 KB
Program Size 648 KB
Free Program Space 352 KB
Free Memory 24.9 KB

[DanielH1987]

As soon as I upgraded from 14.1 to 14.2 for the first time the issue existed.
Maybe that wasn't clear...

[sfromis]

To be clear, what I meant was more that the output from AdcParam after the downgrade + re-upgrade might not be the same as after the first upgrade. While this may not be a causal factor, it might influence how the specifics are visible now. What you posted showed (as you noticed) that something was broken, where the circumstances of this may be "more interesting" than if it worked or not, when it comes to looking for, and fixing, an issue.