[🐞]: Some undetected wood types and false positive wood types

[FreyrDev]

Code of Conduct

• Always check you are using the latest version of the mods and its dependencies
• Remove mod that enhances Minecraft: Optifine, Sodium, others. The issue still persists.
• If you are unsure which mod is the culprit.
  Disable all of your mods and enable them 1-2 mods each time to isolate the culprit
• Confirm that there is no existing issue with a similar description submitted in the list of issues.

Version - Loader (DO NOT FORGET TO SELECT THE CORRECT VERSION)

1.21.1 - FABRIC

EveryCompat Version

everycomp-1.21-2.8.5-fabric

Moonlight Lib Version

moonlight-1.21-2.17.12-fabric

Issue with mods

• Blockus
• My Nether's Delight Refabricated (Probably also affects other versions of /(My)? Nether's Delight (Refabricated)?/)

Issue Detail

As can be seen here, my testing setup currently adds six new full wood sets:

In order, these are:

• blockus:white_oak
• blockus:charred
• blockus:raw_bamboo
• gardens_of_the_dead:soulblight
• gardens_of_the_dead:whistlecane
• mynethersdelight:powdery

However, when we look at what blocks are added by Every Compat there are only four types:

In order:

• gardens_of_the_dead:soulblight
• gardens_of_the_dead:whistlecane
• blockus:white_oak
• blockus:legacy

So there are two problems here:

Firstly, the false positive detection of blockus:legacy as a wood type. Blockus' legacy blocks are a weird addition and I usually disable them anyway, there are only two blocks in this "wood set": those being blockus:legacy_log and blockus:legacy_planks, none of the other things that usually make up a wood set, and they don't even match with each other. This one admittedly isn't that big of a deal given it's possible to disable it in the everycomp-entries.json config.

Secondly, the fact that blockus:charred, blockus:raw_bamboo, and mynethersdelight:powdery get missed completely by Every Compat. Until I saw whistlecane I had initially just assumed that bamboo type woods weren't included, but now I have no idea what's causing powdery wood to get missed; it's using the same naming conventions as whistlecane and vanilla bamboo. For the other two, I assume they're not getting picked up because they don't have their own log blocks despite having every other block in a normal wood set (doors, signs, fences, etc.).

OPTIONAL: Latest.log | Crash-report Attachment

No response

OPTIONAL: To Produce

No response

[Xelbayria]

1. Whistlecane was manually added to WoodType. it's a type which is similar to "sugarcane".
2. Can you check the undetected woodType having "bass" sound?
3. the block, blockus:legacy only have log and planks, that's it, correct?

[FreyrDev]

All three of charred, raw bamboo, and powdery wood do use bass yes. And yeah legacy only has those two blocks.

[Xelbayria]

Alright,

First,
The following undetected woodTypes are:

• blockus:charred
• blockus:raw_bamboo
• mynethersdelight:powdery

I'll need the Ids of log and planks of these 3 woodTypes.
the powdery, it would be better if it has a block that can be treated as "log" and a planks as planks. Same with raw_bamboo. Once i got the info, I'll add them to Moonlight

Second,
blockus:legacy is good enough for most blocks from supported mods that only require log or planks. but not stripped_log, and other children (trapdoor, door, so on).

Can you clarify regarding blockus:legacy below:

they don't even match with each other.

[Xelbayria]

Ok.

• blockus:charred won't be added.
• blockus:raw_bamboo have been added.
• mynethersdelight:powdery have been updated

[Xelbayria]

UPDATED & ADDED in Moonlight Lib v2.17.18