diff --git a/bbreplay/replay.py b/bbreplay/replay.py
index cbc7ae8..bd8dcb5 100644
--- a/bbreplay/replay.py
+++ b/bbreplay/replay.py
@@ -257,11 +257,7 @@ def _process_kickoff(self, cmds, log_entries, board):
             next(cmds)
             cmd = cmds.peek()
 
-        ball_bounces = True
-        for event in self._process_kickoff_event(cmds, log_entries, board):
-            yield event
-            if isinstance(event, Action) and event.action == ActionType.CATCH:
-                ball_bounces = event.result != ActionResult.SUCCESS
+        yield from self._process_kickoff_event(cmds, log_entries, board)
 
         board.kickoff()
 
@@ -270,9 +266,30 @@ def _process_kickoff(self, cmds, log_entries, board):
         target_half = kickoff_cmd.position.y // half_pitch_length
         landed_half = ball_dest.y // half_pitch_length
 
-        touchback = board.get_ball_position().is_offpitch() or target_half != landed_half
+        ball_position = board.get_ball_position()
+        touchback = ball_position.is_offpitch() or target_half != landed_half
+        if not touchback:
+            under_ball = board.get_position(ball_position)
+        else:
+            under_ball = None
+        ball_carrier = board.get_ball_carrier()
 
-        if ball_bounces:
+        if ball_carrier:
+            # Already caught
+            pass
+        elif under_ball:
+            # We don't use `_process_catch` here because we can't reroll kickoff catches but the process
+            # method uses helpers that assume a failed action rerolls or declines a reroll
+            catch_entry = next(log_entries)
+            validate_log_entry(catch_entry, CatchEntry, board.receiving_team)
+            if catch_entry.result == ActionResult.SUCCESS:
+                board.set_ball_carrier(under_ball)
+                yield Action(under_ball, ActionType.CATCH, catch_entry.result, board)
+            else:
+                yield Action(under_ball, ActionType.CATCH, catch_entry.result, board)
+                yield from self._process_ball_movement(cmds, log_entries, board)
+        else:
+            # No-one to caught it
             if touchback:
                 _ = next(log_entries)
             else:
@@ -284,8 +301,6 @@ def _process_kickoff(self, cmds, log_entries, board):
                     yield Bounce(old_position, ball_dest, log_entry.direction, board)
                 if ball_dest.is_offpitch():
                     touchback = True
-        # else
-        # TODO: Handle no bounce when it gets caught straight away (but not via "High Kick" event)
 
         if touchback:
             cmd = next(cmds)
@@ -394,6 +409,7 @@ def _process_turn(self, cmds, log_entries, expected_team, board):
             next(cmds)
             cmd = cmds.peek()
 
+        # FIXME: Cmd ends up as `None` but we get an infinite loop if we return
         if cmd.team != expected_team:
             # Next command should be from the *other* team. If it's not then something odd happened
             log_entry = log_entries.peek()
diff --git a/dvc.lock b/dvc.lock
index 1a2a597..520079d 100644
--- a/dvc.lock
+++ b/dvc.lock
@@ -4,8 +4,8 @@ stages:
     cmd: python3 metrics.py -o metrics/metrics.json -p metrics/plots.json data/
     deps:
     - path: bbreplay/
-      md5: ccd2944cfcfda74cf3623a466913efc9.dir
-      size: 253530
+      md5: 08eb26111675333ebf70008ff100783b.dir
+      size: 254347
       nfiles: 14
     - path: data/
       md5: 8f4f4d470b87ccc84345c3d35a283af3.dir
@@ -16,8 +16,8 @@ stages:
       size: 3388
     outs:
     - path: metrics/metrics.json
-      md5: f56c4c2db42aff5cd1ed00475d2a9252
-      size: 5275
+      md5: 2aac44f254e4f7ca69bcb4c1df77a96f
+      size: 5274
     - path: metrics/plots.json
-      md5: 28131053b0fd11416298f2854e74e302
-      size: 1753
+      md5: c960b6c4c5fb39c8753cd4070f0111f0
+      size: 1738
diff --git a/metrics/metrics.json b/metrics/metrics.json
index 7cc1b43..4707a33 100644
--- a/metrics/metrics.json
+++ b/metrics/metrics.json
@@ -1,8 +1,8 @@
 {
     "total_commands": 140177,
-    "total_processed": 44326,
-    "total_unprocessed": 95851,
-    "weighted_proportion": 0.4046040189978087,
+    "total_processed": 44354,
+    "total_unprocessed": 95823,
+    "weighted_proportion": 0.4048177708776801,
     "results": {
         "data/Replay_2021-04-05_11-35-42.db": {
             "commands": 42,
@@ -174,9 +174,9 @@
         },
         "data/Replay_2021-04-11_10-04-51.db": {
             "commands": 4517,
-            "events": 788,
-            "processed": 4489,
-            "unprocessed": 28
+            "events": 795,
+            "processed": 4517,
+            "unprocessed": 0
         }
     }
 }
\ No newline at end of file
diff --git a/metrics/plots.json b/metrics/plots.json
index d0ed438..2bb2b59 100644
--- a/metrics/plots.json
+++ b/metrics/plots.json
@@ -73,7 +73,7 @@
             "score": 0.8461538461538461
         },
         {
-            "score": 0.9938011954837281
+            "score": 1.0
         },
         {
             "score": 1.0
diff --git a/tests/test_replay__kickoff.py b/tests/test_replay__kickoff.py
index 4848aec..7ff2eef 100644
--- a/tests/test_replay__kickoff.py
+++ b/tests/test_replay__kickoff.py
@@ -15,8 +15,8 @@ def test_normal_kick(board):
         PreKickoffCompleteCommand(1, 0, TeamType.HOME.value, 0, [TeamType.HOME.value])
     ])
     log_entries = iter_([
-        KickDirectionLogEntry(TeamType.AWAY.name, "1", ScatterDirection.S.value),
-        KickDistanceLogEntry(TeamType.AWAY.name, "1", 1),
+        KickDirectionLogEntry(TeamType.AWAY, "1", ScatterDirection.S.value),
+        KickDistanceLogEntry(TeamType.AWAY, "1", 1),
         KickoffEventLogEntry(KickoffEvent.CHEERING_FANS.value),
         BounceLogEntry(ScatterDirection.N.value)
     ])
@@ -64,8 +64,8 @@ def test_normal_kick_very_sunny(board):
         PreKickoffCompleteCommand(1, 0, TeamType.HOME.value, 0, [TeamType.HOME.value])
     ])
     log_entries = iter_([
-        KickDirectionLogEntry(TeamType.AWAY.name, "1", ScatterDirection.S.value),
-        KickDistanceLogEntry(TeamType.AWAY.name, "1", 1),
+        KickDirectionLogEntry(TeamType.AWAY, "1", ScatterDirection.S.value),
+        KickDistanceLogEntry(TeamType.AWAY, "1", 1),
         KickoffEventLogEntry(KickoffEvent.CHANGING_WEATHER.value),
         WeatherLogEntry(Weather.VERY_SUNNY.name),
         BounceLogEntry(ScatterDirection.N.value),
@@ -115,6 +115,119 @@ def test_normal_kick_very_sunny(board):
     assert not next(log_entries, None)
 
 
+def test_catch_on_kick(board):
+    home_team, away_team = board.teams
+    player = home_team.get_player(0)
+    board.set_position(Position(8, 14), player)
+    replay = Replay(home_team, away_team, [], [])
+    cmds = iter_([
+        SetupCompleteCommand(1, 0, TeamType.AWAY.value, 0, []),
+        SetupCommand(1, 0, TeamType.HOME.value, 0, [TeamType.HOME.value, 0, 8, 14]),
+        SetupCompleteCommand(1, 0, TeamType.HOME.value, 0, []),
+        KickoffCommand(1, 0, TeamType.AWAY.value, 0, [8, 15]),
+        PreKickoffCompleteCommand(1, 0, TeamType.HOME.value, 0, [TeamType.HOME.value])
+    ])
+    log_entries = iter_([
+        KickDirectionLogEntry(TeamType.AWAY, "1", ScatterDirection.S.value),
+        KickDistanceLogEntry(TeamType.AWAY, "1", 1),
+        KickoffEventLogEntry(KickoffEvent.CHEERING_FANS.value),
+        CatchEntry(TeamType.HOME, "1", "2+", "2", ActionResult.SUCCESS)
+    ])
+    events = replay._process_kickoff(cmds, log_entries, board)
+
+    event = next(events)
+    assert isinstance(event, TeamSetupComplete)
+    assert event.team == TeamType.AWAY
+
+    event = next(events)
+    assert isinstance(event, TeamSetupComplete)
+    assert event.team == TeamType.HOME
+
+    event = next(events)
+    assert isinstance(event, SetupComplete)
+
+    event = next(events)
+    assert isinstance(event, Kickoff)
+    assert event.target == Position(8, 15)
+    assert event.scatter_direction == ScatterDirection.S
+    assert event.scatter_distance == 1
+    assert board.get_ball_position() == Position(8, 14)
+
+    event = next(events)
+    assert isinstance(event, KickoffEventTuple)
+    assert event.result == KickoffEvent.CHEERING_FANS
+
+    event = next(events)
+    assert isinstance(event, Action)
+    assert event.action == ActionType.CATCH
+    assert event.result == ActionResult.SUCCESS
+
+    assert board.get_ball_carrier() == player
+
+    assert not next(events, None)
+    assert not next(cmds, None)
+    assert not next(log_entries, None)
+
+
+def test_failed_catch_on_kick(board):
+    home_team, away_team = board.teams
+    replay = Replay(home_team, away_team, [], [])
+    cmds = iter_([
+        SetupCompleteCommand(1, 0, TeamType.AWAY.value, 0, []),
+        SetupCommand(1, 0, TeamType.HOME.value, 0, [TeamType.HOME.value, 0, 8, 14]),
+        SetupCompleteCommand(1, 0, TeamType.HOME.value, 0, []),
+        KickoffCommand(1, 0, TeamType.AWAY.value, 0, [8, 15]),
+        PreKickoffCompleteCommand(1, 0, TeamType.HOME.value, 0, [TeamType.HOME.value])
+    ])
+    log_entries = iter_([
+        KickDirectionLogEntry(TeamType.AWAY, "1", ScatterDirection.S.value),
+        KickDistanceLogEntry(TeamType.AWAY, "1", 1),
+        KickoffEventLogEntry(KickoffEvent.CHEERING_FANS.value),
+        CatchEntry(TeamType.HOME, "1", "2+", "1", ActionResult.FAILURE),
+        BounceLogEntry(ScatterDirection.N.value)
+    ])
+    events = replay._process_kickoff(cmds, log_entries, board)
+
+    event = next(events)
+    assert isinstance(event, TeamSetupComplete)
+    assert event.team == TeamType.AWAY
+
+    event = next(events)
+    assert isinstance(event, TeamSetupComplete)
+    assert event.team == TeamType.HOME
+
+    event = next(events)
+    assert isinstance(event, SetupComplete)
+
+    event = next(events)
+    assert isinstance(event, Kickoff)
+    assert event.target == Position(8, 15)
+    assert event.scatter_direction == ScatterDirection.S
+    assert event.scatter_distance == 1
+    assert board.get_ball_position() == Position(8, 14)
+
+    event = next(events)
+    assert isinstance(event, KickoffEventTuple)
+    assert event.result == KickoffEvent.CHEERING_FANS
+
+    event = next(events)
+    assert isinstance(event, Action)
+    assert event.action == ActionType.CATCH
+    assert event.result == ActionResult.FAILURE
+
+    event = next(events)
+    assert isinstance(event, Bounce)
+    assert event.scatter_direction == ScatterDirection.N
+    assert event.start_space == Position(8, 14)
+    assert event.end_space == Position(8, 15)
+
+    assert board.get_ball_carrier() is None
+
+    assert not next(events, None)
+    assert not next(cmds, None)
+    assert not next(log_entries, None)
+
+
 def test_touchback_for_off_pitch_kick(board):
     home_team, away_team = board.teams
     replay = Replay(home_team, away_team, [], [])
@@ -127,8 +240,8 @@ def test_touchback_for_off_pitch_kick(board):
         TouchbackCommand(1, 0, TeamType.HOME.value, 0, [TeamType.HOME.value, 0])
     ])
     log_entries = iter_([
-        KickDirectionLogEntry(TeamType.AWAY.name, "1", ScatterDirection.SW.value),
-        KickDistanceLogEntry(TeamType.AWAY.name, "1", 6),
+        KickDirectionLogEntry(TeamType.AWAY, "1", ScatterDirection.SW.value),
+        KickDistanceLogEntry(TeamType.AWAY, "1", 6),
         KickoffEventLogEntry(KickoffEvent.CHEERING_FANS.value),
         BounceLogEntry(ScatterDirection.NW.value)
     ])
@@ -176,8 +289,8 @@ def test_touchback_for_off_pitch_bounce(board):
         TouchbackCommand(1, 0, TeamType.HOME.value, 0, [TeamType.HOME.value, 0])
     ])
     log_entries = iter_([
-        KickDirectionLogEntry(TeamType.AWAY.name, "1", ScatterDirection.SW.value),
-        KickDistanceLogEntry(TeamType.AWAY.name, "1", 1),
+        KickDirectionLogEntry(TeamType.AWAY, "1", ScatterDirection.SW.value),
+        KickDistanceLogEntry(TeamType.AWAY, "1", 1),
         KickoffEventLogEntry(KickoffEvent.CHEERING_FANS.value),
         BounceLogEntry(ScatterDirection.S.value)
     ])
@@ -231,8 +344,8 @@ def test_touchback_for_own_half_kick(board):
         TouchbackCommand(1, 0, TeamType.HOME.value, 0, [TeamType.HOME.value, 0])
     ])
     log_entries = iter_([
-        KickDirectionLogEntry(TeamType.AWAY.name, "1", ScatterDirection.S.value),
-        KickDistanceLogEntry(TeamType.AWAY.name, "1", 1),
+        KickDirectionLogEntry(TeamType.AWAY, "1", ScatterDirection.S.value),
+        KickDistanceLogEntry(TeamType.AWAY, "1", 1),
         KickoffEventLogEntry(KickoffEvent.CHEERING_FANS.value),
         BounceLogEntry(ScatterDirection.W.value)
     ])
@@ -280,8 +393,8 @@ def test_touchback_for_own_half_kick_other_direction(board):
         TouchbackCommand(1, 0, TeamType.HOME.value, 0, [TeamType.HOME.value, 0])
     ])
     log_entries = iter_([
-        KickDirectionLogEntry(TeamType.AWAY.name, "1", ScatterDirection.N.value),
-        KickDistanceLogEntry(TeamType.AWAY.name, "1", 1),
+        KickDirectionLogEntry(TeamType.AWAY, "1", ScatterDirection.N.value),
+        KickDistanceLogEntry(TeamType.AWAY, "1", 1),
         KickoffEventLogEntry(KickoffEvent.CHEERING_FANS.value),
         BounceLogEntry(ScatterDirection.W.value)
     ])